ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
85°
Broken Clouds
H 87° L 64°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    85°
    Current Conditions
    Clear. H 87° L 64°
  • clear-night
    65°
    Morning
    Clear. H 87° L 64°
  • clear-day Created with Sketch.
    83°
    Afternoon
    Sunny. H 88° L 66°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Corrine Brown's district targeted by new federal lawsuit
Close

Corrine Brown's district targeted by new federal lawsuit

Corrine Brown's district targeted by new federal lawsuit
Florida's 5th Congressional District as of 2014

Corrine Brown's district targeted by new federal lawsuit

Democratic Congresswoman Corrine Brown’s district is being challenged in a federal lawsuit by two voters who argue it violates their constitutional rights.

WOKV News obtained the amended formal complaint filed Thursday, which alleges that “Florida’s Congressional District 5 is racially gerrymandered in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.”

This isn’t the first legal challenge to Florida’s districts since they were redrawn in 2012, the first time that lawmakers faced the anti-gerrymandering “Fair Districts” amendments approved by voters in 2010. One of the two men filing the District 5 lawsuit, William Everett Warinner, is part of an ongoing state lawsuit against the maps and the 2012 Congressional Plan as a whole.

Warinner’s federal lawsuit claims “race played a predominant role in the drawing of Congressional District 5,” citing evidence of an “unjustifiable concentration” of African-American voters, the “bizarre shape” of the district, and its failure “to utilize existing political and geographical boundaries.”

It alleges that Florida’s 5th Congressional District violates the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment and asks that it be redrawn to conform to it.  It says Warinner and co-plaintiff James C. Miller Sr. “are reasonably concerned that those issues of state constitutional law will not be resolved in time to achieve effective relief before the 2014 congressional elections.”

According to the complaint, “African-American voters are unnecessarily packed” into the district.”  It cites a Black Voting Age Population (“BVAP”) of 50.1%.  It contrasts that with the BVAP of nearby congressional districts: 13.2% (District 3), 12.9% (District 4), and 9.1% (District 6).

The lawsuit claims that one of the ways the Florida Legislature packed African-American voters into the district was by “moving a significant part of the African-American population out of the town of Sanford, previously in Congressional District 7, into Congressional District 5.  Then, to make up for that population loss, they moved part of Forest City, a subu8rb with an approximately 80% white population, into Congressional District 7.”

The unusual shape of District 5 is a focus of the complaint.  “Compactness is a neutral redistricting criterion recognized under both state and federal law” the lawsuit says at the beginning of the section.  It then says the District’s shape has all the features that the Florida Supreme Court would refer to as “constitutionally suspect and often indicative of racial and partisan gerrymandering” including “finger-like extensions,” “narrow and bizarrely shaped tentacles,” and “hook-like shapes.”

In an effort to give minority voters a voice, District 5 stretches out across eight counties: Duval, Clay, Putnam, Alachua, Marion, Lake, Seminole, and Orange.  The complaint notes that the next highest “county split” in Florida is four.

“Congressional District 5’s failure to utilize existing political and geographical boundaries…indicates that race was a predominant factor in the creation of Congressional District 5,” the lawsuit says.

The defendant named in the case is Secretary of State Ken Detzner.  Both of the plaintiffs are registered voters in Gainesville, which is included in Congresswoman Corrine Brown’s district.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • A North Carolina county could be in major violation of HIPPA laws after mistakenly releasing hundreds of patients’ private medical records to a Charlotte TV station that was investigating a medical story. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, or HIPPA, was enacted in 1996 to ensure patient privacy rights. >> Read more trending news Mecklenburg County manager Dena Diorio revealed Tuesday afternoon that the county mistakenly released the private medical records of some 1,200 patients to the media. The county attorney confirmed patient health information was compromised.  'I'm absolutely speechless with anger at how something like this could happen,' Diorio said. Channel 9 had requested public records related to the county's failure to notify nearly 200 women about abnormal Pap smear results.  While WSOC-TV received that information Monday, the county also mistakenly included detailed medical history about hundreds of patients. The information included an Excel spreadsheets documenting the patients’ full names, addresses and dates of visits.  For some patients it also included a detailed description of why they visited and what services they received. Diorio said the information should not have been in spreadsheets in the email and the practice of putting medical information in Excel sheets will end immediately. Diorio said she believes the release is a category 2 HIPAA violation with a minimum fine of $1,000 per violation up to $50,000. A county worker collected the records Tuesday morning from WSOC.  “We do everything we can to protect the personal information for all of our patients,” Mecklenburg County Manager Dena Diorio said. “In this particular instance, the checks and balances were not completely followed and we had a lapse.' Diorio said an IT staffer mistakenly included the information in the public records request. She also said no one checked the file before it was released. >> Got a question about the news? See our explainers here “This was a person who works in our IT security area so it’s not as if everybody has access to this information,” she said. It’s unclear if the hundreds of patients will be notified about the information leak. Diorio is planning to discuss the next steps with the county attorney on Tuesday.   >> Click here to read the full story.
  • Seven children and a school bus driver have been taken to the hospital after they reported feeling sick. Jacksonville Fire and Rescue says 20-025 children said they didn’t feel well. Seven were transported to the hospital as a precaution, but all are said to be in good condition.  The children and driver were on a school bus in the Hogan’s Creek area. JFRD suspected carbon monoxide, but when they tested there was nothing abnormal at the scene.  This is a developing story that will be updated in to the evening.
  • Days after a child was kidnapped from Elite Academy Inc., the Memphis, Tennessee, day care has closed its doors for good. >> Read more trending news A Department of Human Services spokesperson said an investigation into the day care is ongoing, but the owner voluntarily shut down the business. The closure is permanent. Related: Mother speaks out after 7-month-old is kidnapped from day care On Thursday, 7-month-old A’Laleh Fentress was checked out from her day care by 18-year-old Mya Lakes. Lakes is charged with especially aggravated kidnapping and child abuse/neglect. Her bail is $100,000. A’Laleh’s mother said Lakes saw her name on a document at the day care and used it to check out the child. The 7-month-old’s mother called police from the day care when she came to pick her baby up that evening. A’Laleh was later found safe at Annie’s Place in Frayser. Related: Memphis day care at center of kidnapping had no previous violations Elite Academy Inc. has been inspected by the DHS at least eight times since it opened in August 2016. According to the government database, the day care was never cited for violations.
  • Nearly 9 months after a shooting in Northwest Jacksonville claimed the lives of Demetrius Robinson, 31, and Jennie Hawley, 34, the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office has made an arrest.   Gerrod Wilson, 23, is now in police custody after the Criminal Apprehension Unit located him Monday.   Wilson is charged with murder and possessing a firearm as a convicted felon in connection to the July 1st, 2016 shooting on Dekle Avenue.  Wilson's girlfriend, Charity Coleman, 24, was also arrested and she's charged for being an accessory after the fact, which is a first degree felony charge.   JSO says Coleman was arrested for that same offense back in February, when detectives say they discovered she was harboring Wilson in her apartment.   We’re told the arrests were a collaborative effort involving everyone from patrol and enforcement to the Department of Investigations and Homeland Security.
  • At the request of four Democrats in the Congress, the Government Accountability Office has agreed to formally review how much money the feds spend, and what security precautions are taken, when President Donald Trump takes a weekend away at his Mar-a-Lago retreat in Palm Beach, Florida. The request for a GAO review came from three Democratic Senators and one House member – the GAO says it will “review security and site-related travel expenses related to the President’s stays outside the White House at Mar-a-Lago. The lawmakers who made the request were Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), Sen. Tom Udall (D-NM), Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), and Rep. Elijah Cummings (D-MD). On 2/16, @RepCummings @SenWarren @SenWhitehouse & I wrote @USGAO & asked they review Mar-a-Lago security procedures & taxpayer funded travel — Tom Udall (@SenatorTomUdall) March 28, 2017 This is not new territory for the GAO, which from time to time is asked by one party or the other to review the costs of travel. When the White House was under the control of Democrats, Republicans a few years ago were the ones asking about costs – as they had the GAO look at a February 15-18, 2013 trip made by President Barack Obama. In that review, the GAO estimated that an official speech in Illinois, followed by a golf weekend in Florida, cost about $3.6 million. This GAO report will look at more than just the cost of the weekend trips to Trump’s resort in Mar-a-Lago, as it will also review security matters there. (CBSMiami/AP) — A government watchdog will investigate the taxpayer-funded travel costs of President Donald Trump’s trips to Mar-a-lago. — Liz Quirantes (@lizquirantes) March 28, 2017 Democrats raised those concerns during a trip that Mr. Trump took with the Japanese Prime Minister, when the two men were seen with aides in a public dining area, speaking about a developing national security issue with regards to North Korea. One question from the four Democrats centers on whether those who are at the Trump club have gone through normal security and clearance procedures, including any foreign nationals who might be there. White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer has downplayed the costs of the Mar-a-Lago visits, saying that’s ‘part of being President.’ “That is a vast reach,” Spicer told one reporter, who cast the question of the cost of the Mar-a-Lago visits, versus proposed cuts in the federal budget. Before he became President, Mr. Trump often criticized his predecessor for taking weekend golf trips to Florida and other parts of the country. While our wonderful president was out playing golf all day, the TSA is falling apart, just like our government! Airports a total disaster! — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) May 21, 2016 The GAO will now be in charge of determining how much Mr. Trump’s own weekend getaways are costing taxpayers.

The Latest News Videos