ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day
76°
Mostly Cloudy
H 80° L 63°
  • cloudy-day
    76°
    Current Conditions
    Mostly Cloudy. H 80° L 63°
  • cloudy-day
    64°
    Morning
    Mostly Cloudy. H 80° L 63°
  • clear-day
    77°
    Afternoon
    Mostly Sunny. H 80° L 66°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Duval County School Board votes in favor of joining lawsuit, challenging constitutionality of HB 7069
Close

Duval County School Board votes in favor of joining lawsuit, challenging constitutionality of HB 7069

Duval County School Board votes in favor of joining lawsuit, challenging constitutionality of HB 7069

Duval County School Board votes in favor of joining lawsuit, challenging constitutionality of HB 7069

It's an idea the Duval County School Board first floated at a special meeting back in July, now, they're moving forward.  

Board members have voted, 4-2, in favor of joining a proposed lawsuit with other school districts against the State of Florida, that challenges the constitutionality of controversial House Bill 7069.  

The bill, which was signed by Governor Rick Scott earlier this year, in part, threatens to shut down low performing schools and turn them into charter schools.  

Board chairman Paula Wright, who voted in favor, sent WOKV the following statement:  

“This lawsuit is to determine the constitutionality of HB 7069. It will answer a fundamental question- has the legislators crossed the line of impeding on the constitutional authority given to school board members. This lawsuit is about certain provisions of HB 7069 that intrude on the School Board’s explicit constitutional duty to operate, supervise and control all free public schools in the district.”

Board member Becki Couch has also released a statement, explaining why she also voted in favor of joining the suit.

Couch says, “I voted for the legal challenge of HB7069 because I believe there are unconstitutional elements of the bill. This is not about opposing school choice, opposing teacher bonus pay, or protecting the status quo, as some will proclaim. I support utilizing the judicial branch of government as a means to challenge whether or not a law that takes away representation by an elected body and hands it over to an unelected and unaccountable body, is constitutional. As a fiscal conservative I have grave concerns over the way in which over $16 million of property tax revenue can be diverted to for profit entities with no requirement to demonstrate need and with no requirement that the buildings belong to the taxpayer (local school boards are required to demonstrate need). I have grave concern over the fact that HB7069 establishes charter schools as local education agencies (LEA) without oversight from the taxpayer through an elected board, and I have grave concern that HB7069 eliminates the representative democracy that keeps the local decision making closest to the people. Our founding fathers established the three branches of government to ensure there are checks and balances in government. In this case, I believe the only body that can demonstrate legal standing to challenge the constitutionality of HB7069 is a school board. Therefore, it is incumbent upon us to ensure the law that was passed does not violate the state constitution we were sworn to uphold.”

Meanwhile, board member Scott Shine was one of two votes against joining the lawsuit.

He worries the lawsuit will impede the district's ability to work with the Florida legislature to solve some of the problems within the bill.  

"I think, in general, litigation sends the wrong message to the legislature, that we're in an adversarial position when we should be in a cooperative position," says Shine.  

Shine admits there are problems with HB 7069, but he says it can be refined.  

"This was the first year that this bill hit the floor and was voted in. When that happens, virtually every time in the legislature, there are refinements, there are new laws passed to make a law better and that's part of the natural process. It's only been a few months that this bill has been enacted into law and we're already engaged in litigation with the state. I think that's premature," explains Shine.  

Shine tells WOKV that in order to join the litigation, the district will be making a $25,000 financial commitment, which he says 'supposedly' does not come out of educational services.

Duval County Public Schools has posted the following statement on their website about Monday’s vote:

“The Duval County Public School Board voted Monday to join a proposed lawsuit that will challenge the constitutionality of a controversial education law the Florida Legislature passed this spring.  

The other school boards that have authorized litigation include Bay, Broward, Hamilton, Lee, Miami-Date, Orange, Palm Beach, Polk, St. Lucie and Volusia. Each school district will financially participate on a pro-rated basis per student enrollment.  

Duval County Public School’s portion of the litigation expenses would be paid from non-public funds, not to exceed $25,000, without School Board approval. The Office of the General Counsel has estimated expenses to be $400,000, if the challenge goes to trial.”

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • The St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office is asking for your help in trying to find Steven Christofer Haramia who deputies say left his residence early Saturday morning, possibly around 3am. Deputies say Haramia has several medical conditions which require continued medication. The sheriff’s office says Haramia was last seen wearing a white t-shirt and a camouflage jacket, with black Nike shoes. Deputies describe him as 5’9, 155 lbs, with black hair and brown eyes.  The sheriff’s office said they were searching for Haramia Sunday with their helicopter near the Heritage Park community in St. Augustine.  Deputies say if you know where Haramia is you can call the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office at 904-824-8304.      
  • Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel blasted politicians after a gunman killed 17 people at a Parkland, Florida, high school, saying that if gun laws don’t change, “you will not get re-elected in Broward County.” >> WATCH: Florida school shooting survivor Emma Gonzalez slams politicians, NRA in emotional speech According to the Huffington Post, while speaking at a vigil in Parkland for the victims of the shooting, Israel said, “If you’re an elected official, and you want to keep things the way they are ― if you want to keep gun laws as they are now ― you will not get re-elected in Broward County.” >> Click here to watch The vigil was attended by thousands at an amphitheater that was lit by candles and had 17 4-foot angels – one for each of the victims who was killed at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. >> On Rare.us: 'Thoughts and prayers' check raises eyebrows on social media after the Florida shooting Last week, Israel called on lawmakers to allow law enforcement officers to involuntarily detain people who post questionable and disturbing content on social media. “We need to have the power to take that person and bring them before mental health professionals at that particular time, involuntarily, and have them examined,” he said, the Huffington Post reported. “People are going to be rightfully concerned about their rights ― as am I. But what about these students? What about the rights of young kids who go to schools?” >> PHOTOS: Remembering Parkland, Florida, school shooting victims He added that he wishes law enforcement officials could act “if they see something on social media, if they see graphic pictures of rifles and blood and gore and guns and bombs, if they see something, horrific language, if they see a person talking about ‘I want to grow up to be a serial killer.’” Democrats in Congress are already calling for gun control while Republicans are saying that it’s too soon to talk about it. >> Classmate of Nikolas Cruz: ‘No one has ever been a friend to him’ Speaker of the House Paul Ryan said during a press conference Thursday that we need to think less about fighting “each other politically” in the wake of the shooting. “This is one of those moments where we just need to step back and count our blessings,” he said Thursday at a news conference, according to CNN. “We need to think less about taking sides and fighting each other politically, and just pulling together. This House, and the whole country, stands with the Parkland community.” >> Florida school shooting timeline: Seven minutes, three floors and 17 dead Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., tweeted that Congress should vote on measures to implement “universal background checks, a ban on military-style weapons and a prohibition of those on the terror watchlist from purchasing firearms.” >> Read more trending news  Florida Sen. Bill Nelson, a Democrat, said Congress will have “another round” of this debate, but admitted that it’s hard to get any sort of gun legislation passed. Read more here.
  • Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, where 17 people were killed Wednesday by a gunman, will reopen Thursday, according to a statement from Broward County Public Schools. >> Read more trending news Only staff members will be allowed back on the sprawling campus in northwest Broward County. There is no mention in the statement when students will be permitted to return. The school remains a crime scene and will be closed through Wednesday. Nikolas Cruz, 19, a former student at the school, is facing 17 first-degree murder counts after he confessed to shooting 14 students and three staff members around 2:30 p.m.
  • As of early Sunday morning, FDOT says for the next 2 years, traffic will be shifted on the Fuller Warren Bridge beginning at the Park Street ramp all the way past the San Marco Boulevard exit. FDOT says drivers heading south will see lanes shift to the inside and that shift will create a work zone for construction crews to start expansion work on the Fuller Warren as part of the Your 10&95 project. We told you about this shift back in November, and due to weather and other circumstances, its been pushed back until today. FDOT says, as part of the project, construction crews will be adding another lane on I-95 in both directions on the Fuller Warren as well as a Shared Use Path. The path will be available for people walking or riding their bike from Riverside to San Marco, or vice versa. FDOT is urging drivers to use caution through this area, for your safty, as well as the construction crews safty. The Your 10&95 project is projected to be compleated by the summer of 2020.
  • Construction crews have been working on the Florida Department of Transportation’s Your10&95 project since May of 2017.  While crews have nearly a year of construction under their belt, the project still has two more years to go. FDOT says they expect the complete project to be done by the summer of 2020.  The goal of the Your10&95 project is to make operational improvements and enhancements to the interchange at I-95 and I-10, The Fuller Warren Bridge, and along east side of U.S. 17 north between McDuff Avenue and Rosselle Street. FDOT says the construction is necessary to cope with the increasing volume of traffic.  “Approximately 250,000 vehicles use the interchange every day, but that is expected to rise dramatically to approximately 290,000 daily users in 2040.” Changes to I-95 and the Fuller Warren: This project will widen the Fuller Warren Bridge expanding northbound and southbound lanes from three lanes to four. Construction crews will also add a Shared Use Path on the Fuller Warren for pedestrians and bicyclists connecting San Marco and Riverside neighborhoods. Pedestrians and bicyclists will not have to worry about their safety, FDOT says they will be separated from traffic by a 10-foot shoulder and a stand barrier wall that is three and a half feet, with an additional curved fence. FDOT says a traffic shift is expected to happen on I-95 southbound along the Fuller Warren Bridge during the month of February. It was originally slated to happen on December 4th, 2017. FDOT says the southbound to the inside of the Fuller Warren Bridge beginning at the Park Street ramp, and go back to its normal configuration after the exit ramp to San Marco Boulevard.  Changes to I-10:  Construction crews will be working to provide a dedicated ramp to Irene and Stockton Street. This is aimed at reducing the weaving traffic merging from I-95 southbound to I-10 west. FDOT says crews will be widening the overpass from I-95 north to I-10 westbound, allowing for future improvements along I-10 west. When it comes to lane closures on the interstates, FDOT says they do not plan to have lanes closed during the day between 5:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Changes to U.S. 17 North: New sound barriers will be built for the neighborhoods along the east side of U.S. 17 north from McDuff Avenue to Rosselle Street. FDOT says there will be lane closures on U.S. 17 North to make this a reality. However, lane closures will not happen between 6 a.m. – 10 a.m. and no closures southbound on U.S. 17 from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. The Florida Department of Transportation hired Archer Western as the contractor to complete this project for $126 million.  Click here to learn more about the Your10&95 project and to get a heads up on when you can expect to see lane closures and shifts for your ride.   

The Latest News Videos