ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

Sponsored By: Two Men and a Truck
cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
75°
Partly Cloudy
H 94° L 76°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    75°
    Current Conditions
    Partly Cloudy. H 94° L 76°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    90°
    Afternoon
    Partly Cloudy. H 94° L 76°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    89°
    Evening
    Partly Cloudy. H 94° L 76°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Pressure on Public Defender's Office mounts
Close

Pressure on Public Defender's Office mounts

Pressure on Public Defender's Office mounts
Photo Credit: Action News
Matt Shirk

Pressure on Public Defender's Office mounts

The Public Defender's Office in Jacksonville is making changes after investigations by Action News and the Florida Times-Union.

We first told you Monday about public records hidden from Action News while we investigated possible inappropriate behavior by Public Defender Matt Shirk against young women on his staff.

Tuesday, the Florida Times-Union reported on records they requested, being deleted by members of Shirk's staff.

The T-U requested key card information for Shirk's wife, Michelle.  Those key cards show when a card holder enters the Public Defender's Office, or enters secure areas in the office.  The T-U had to have the city's IT department find the records after they had been deleted. 

Public records Action News obtained Tuesday show two different employees deleted key card information for Michelle Shirk and the couple's son on the morning of August 14.  We still do not know why employees deleted that information. 

Action News made multiple requests for comments Tuesday about the data deletion, and why the two non-employees had key cards.   We received a response via text saying that the Public Defender's Office is working to find someone else to handle their public records requests.  No local government agency has ever responded to Action News in that way until now.

Why is this so important?

Two sources tell Action News that Michelle Shirk entered the office on June 13, and fired office employee Tiffany Ice.  Michelle Shirk did not have authority to fire office employees. 

Key card swipes show Michelle Shirk at the office that day. 

So why was she there?

A resignation letter obtained by Action News questions Matt Shirk.  Former investigator Greg Strickland states Shirk made "some bad decisions regarding your personal life and marriage."  Strickland submitted that letter, and resigned on July 22.

That is the same day Action News first requested information on the resignation of former Director of Investigations Alton Kelly.

The Public Defender's Office originally denied any resignation letter from Kelly.  They finally delivered the resignation email, dated July 15. 

Back to key card information: Our records indicate Matt Shirk swiped his card very few times during a five-week span in June and July.

He did not swipe his card to enter the building on June 13, the same day his wife reportedly stopped at the office.

Records show Shirk only swiped his card to enter his office building 14 out of the next 54 workdays.

Matt Shirk is expected to announce an independent commission Wednesday to handle public records requests.   We hope he will answer our questions as well.

A statement from the governor Tuesday evening called the recent allegations troubling.  

"If true, would be inconsistent with the high standards of ethical behavior Governor (Rick) Scott expects from public officials," the statement read.

The chairman of the Duval Democratic Party is calling for the Governor's Office to investigate.

Duval Democratic Party Chair Neil Henrichsen released a statement that read as follows:

“The information coming out in the Florida Times-Union about Public Defender Matt Shirk’s office allegedly destroying public documents and engaging in improper employment practices is deeply concerning and a betrayal of the public trust,” said Duval County Democratic Party Chair Neil Henrichsen. “I call on Governor Scott to suspend Shirk from his public defender duties while an independent investigation by a state attorney outside of Fourth Judicial Circuit is conducted to look into if the law was broken. If the allegations prove to be true, Shirk should resign his position immediately.”

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • Thousands of residents in a north London housing complex were evacuated from their apartments Friday night after fire checks revealed the buildings were unsafe, Reuters reported. >> Read more trending news The checks were done in the wake of the Grenfell Tower fire on June 14. Residents, along with their children and pets were removed from five tower blocks and headed to a local sports center to sleep on air beds, Reuters reported. “I know it’s difficult but Grenfell changes everything,” Georgia Gould, leader of Camden Council, said in the statement. “I don’t believe we can take any risks with our residents’ safety.” The London Fire Brigade said it had found a number of fire safety issues at the Chalcots Estate in Camden and advised residents to leave the building until they were resolved, Reuters reported.
  • A scare happened at a Leominster, Massachusetts, supermarket after a 4-day-old newborn was left locked inside of a hot car while her mother was inside shopping. >> Read more trending news Mother Sharma Murphy said that on her way to Market Basket supermarket on Friday, she stopped by the fire house to make sure her baby’s car seat was properly installed. Less than an hour later, those firefighters helped rescue her 4-day-old baby, who was locked in her hot car. A shopper called Leominster police after spotting a newborn alone inside a car. It was Sharma Murphy's silver Chevy Malibu. >> A reminder of hot car dangers as temperatures climb Murphy said she was out for the first time with her newborn daughter, 4-day-old Katherine, and was nervous. “I went, I bought it. Came right out and this lady just starts screaming at me. Screaming at me,” said Murphy. Murphy said she brought her newborn inside with her to Market Basket and then returned to the car when Katherine fell asleep. She said that she ran back inside for two or three minutes to buy some baby formula. “I went (in and) I bought it,” Murphy said. “(I) came right out and this lady just starts screaming at me.” Related: Two toddlers dead after 15 hours in hot car, police say Police said the windows were rolled up. “I believe she locked her keys in the car because they had to use the jimmy to get the baby out,” witness John Casey told WFXT. According to WFXT meteorologists, the outside temperature was 84 degrees at the time. Murphy said she didn’t want to wake her newborn. “I thought, ‘OK, if I run in and run out...’ It was one of those things where she's gotta eat because I have nothing left for her and that's when everything happened and I'm like, oh my God,” Murphy said. Katherine was taken to the hospital to be checked out. Her mother said he is fine. The baby is currently in custody of DCF. No charges have been filed.
  • Police in Georgia are hoping surveillance video that captured a violent attack will help them find the people responsible. Video shows a restaurant owner and her teenage daughter being beaten by two customers Thursday afternoon in Baxley, Georgia. >> Read more trending news The victims told police the suspects were unhappy with their order. The verbal argument turned violent when one of the suspects began punching the restaurant owner repeatedly. When the victim’s teenage daughter came out of the car to break up the fight, the male suspect punched her in the face. WJCL reported that Baxley police have issued warrants for the suspects, Nathaniel Smith and Latasha Smith. The pair could be charged with aggravated battery and cruelty to children. The suspects drove away from the restaurant in a cream or tan Cadillac Escalade with tag number REU8495. Officials said they headed north on Highway 144. Anyone with any information about the assault is asked to call the Baxley Police Department at 912-367-8305 or the 911 call center at 912-367-8111.
  • Authorities have identified a 10-year-old boy killed on an Alabama beach this week as Tropical Storm Cindy churned toward shore.  Nolan McCabe, of St. Louis, Missouri, was vacationing in Fort Morgan with his family Wednesday morning when Cindy’s storm surge washed a large log on the beach over the boy. The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that Nolan suffered severe head injuries when the log rolled over his body.  Baldwin County Sheriff Huey Mack estimated that the log was about 14 feet long and weighed several hundred pounds, the Post-Dispatch said.  AL.com reported that Nolan was killed feet away from the front door of the beachfront home in which he and his family were staying.  >> Read more trending news Nolan’s father, Joshua McCabe, told investigators that he was also outside that morning, attending to other children playing on the beach. He ran toward his son when he saw a large wave coming ashore, but was unable to grab Nolan before the log was washed into him.  Efforts by family members, firefighters and emergency medical technicians to resuscitate Nolan were unsuccessful, AL.com reported.  Nolan, an avid cub scout, would have been a fifth-grade student at Wohlwend Elementary in St. Louis in the fall. A statement the Mehlville School District indicated that the boy’s parents and sister were all present when he died.  Nolan was the third elementary student in the school district to die since April, the district’s statement said. One boy was killed in a car crash, and the other was struck by a car while riding his bike.  The parent-teacher organization at Wohlwend Elementary set up a GoFundMe account to help Nolan’s family with the expenses related to his death. 
  • A 9-foot-6 inch sturgeon weighing in at 500 pounds was found pinned Thursday in a radial gate at the Keno Dam in Oregon, according to the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife. >> Read more trending news The fish had sustained a head injury at some point and was dead when officials found it. It is believed to have been one of 221 sturgeons moved in 1958 from the Columbia River to Klamath County. At the time, officials were attempting to create fisheries in the area. However, the fish didn’t take, and officials found no evidence that they were able to spawn in their new homes. “It’s thought the female sturgeon was from the original transplant group,” ODFW said in a Facebook post. “Most of those fish would be from 60 to 70 years old now, with the potential to live nearly 100 years.” District fish biologist Bill Tinniswood said the fish, a female sturgeon, had millions of eggs upon her death. Officials believe that the lack of available male sturgeons to spawn with left the eggs to build up. Two anglers have reported seeing sturgeons on the Upper Klamath Lake this year, Tinniswood said.

The Latest News Videos