On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
77°
Rain
H 77° L 73°
  • cloudy-day
    77°
    Current Conditions
    Rain. H 77° L 73°
  • rain-day
    77°
    Morning
    Rain. H 77° L 73°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    79°
    Afternoon
    Thunderstorms. H 80° L 74°
Listen
Pause
Error

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
El Faro's sister ship highlights potential inspection protocol problems
Close

El Faro's sister ship highlights potential inspection protocol problems

El Faro's sister ship highlights potential inspection protocol problems
Photo Credit: TOTE

El Faro's sister ship highlights potential inspection protocol problems

As the American Bureau of Shipping continues to draw the line on their responsibility over El Faro, the history of her sister ship is highlighting some of the biggest potential concerns.

“It’s the owner’s responsibility to maintain the vessel. The rules and regulations set minimum standards, but overall, it’s the owners responsibility to maintain the condition of the vessel to those rules and standards,” says ABS Assistant Chief of Surveys for the Americas Division Lou O’Donnell.

He was called in front of the Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation for the second time through the course of these public hearing sessions to help further delineate the goals and responsibilities ABS believes exist under the Alternate Compliance Program. ACP is the special inspection program that was over El Faro and is still used for many other commercial vessels, allowing class societies like ABS to do inspection work on behalf of the Coast Guard.

GALLERY: Inside the third MBI hearing session

O’Donnell’s testimony Friday raised questions about whether El Faro’s owner, TOTE Maritime Puerto Rico, reported everything they should have, specifically dealing with El Faro’s sister ship El Yunque.

The Board says an email from July 2015 from El Yunque’s Chief Engineer talked about the port lifeboat engine being full of water. While the questioning and testimony never explicitly stated whether that had been reported to the Coast Guard and ABS, O’Donnell said it would be something that TOTE would be required to report.

“It effects a major pieces of lifesaving equipment,” O’Donnell says.

He says part of the reporting would have required the Captain to also detail alternate steps he was taking to ensure the crew had access to similar lifesaving gear, until the needed repair work could take place.

Board Member Keith Fawcett says the water may have been the result of a test performed on the lifeboat davit system, where the boat was filled with water to add weight. O’Donnell says he would have expected the owner to take precautions to prevent that from happening.

MBI Chair Captain Jason Neubauer presented information about a photo taken inside of a supply fan blister on El Yunque, which showed two drainage holes that were about seven inches by six inches. Neubauer says, according to the ship’s plan, the holes should have been one inch in diameter. While O’Donnell hadn’t approved the plan, he said if it holds to Neubauer’s description, than the holes would have been considered an “unapproved modification”, and those could have created a downflooding concern.

Neubauer says the MBI has documentation that shows the holes were in place in 2014 when El Yunque was in a drydock period. O’Donnell confirms it’s something ABS would have been responsible for catching.

Underwater footage from a survey of El Faro’s wreckage appears to show corresponding holes on El Faro were the one inch diameter, according to Neubauer. The most recent report on the openings on the ship- a special ABS document on a survey and report of load lines- could not be found for El Faro specifically. ABS says this form, an LL-11-D, was generated at ship construction and then updated in 1993 when the ship was extended. While O’Donnell found notes indicating the new form’s existence, the original is kept on the ship. ABS keeps another copy in their files, but El Faro’s was lost during some sort of scanning issue when ABS went digital, according to prior testimony.

GALLERY: El Faro's wreckage

Still another area of questioning showed how ABS could require an owner to investigate a serious issue, under a certain requirement under the International Association of Class Society procedures.

“The PR 17 is a driver to report to the recognized organization who’s doing the management system certification that there could be a possible failure in that safety management system, thereby forcing the owner to do an investigation in to that report, and then respond back to that recognized organization that issues the safety management system certificate,” O’Donnell says.

ABS had issued two PR 17s for El Yunque, one of which dealt with problems with the fire suppression system.

The condition of El Yunque’s vent trunks has been frequently questioned through this hearing session, but O’Donnell says there was no PR 17 specifically for that. The problem started when “extreme wastage” was found in one of her vent trunks, and repairs were ordered for that, but ABS cleared the other ones. Just a few months later, when El Yunque was in drydock to be converted to the Alaskan trade, the Coast Guard found what they determined to be “long term” wastage on other vent trunks.

O’Donnell says they didn’t issue a PR 17 for the initial vent trunk situation because repairs were made immediately.

“So that would mean that you did not see the conditions found to be a symptom of the SMS failure.” Neubauer asked.

“Not at that time,” O’Donnell responded.

He couldn’t speculate on whether he believed the wastage in the other vent trunks would have existed for more than one survey cycle. El Yunque is now being scrapped, instead of being transitioned to a new route.

FULL COVERAGE: El Faro sinking

While O’Donnell says his surveyors and the local Coast Guard sectors have a good relationship, and they’re continually working to improve communication, O’Donnell did dispute some of the claims from the Coast Guard’s Chief of Traveling Inspectors earlier in the week, including his concerns about a certain pressure test not being pushed following a repair to a component of El Faro’s boilers. The ABS surveyor in that case previously told investigators that it’s her discretion how to run the test, and she was concerned pushing the test would create an unsafe situation because of the age of the boiler. O’Donnell says the surveyor is good and detailed, and that he trusts her judgement.

The Chief of Traveling Inspectors, Captain David Flaherty, also conducted an investigation of ACP because of concerns from his staff. While Flaherty’s report hasn’t been made public yet, an ABS attorney read a portion today dealing with his recommendations. According to the reading, Flaherty is recommending ABS not perform class society work and work on behalf of the Coast Guard during the same trip on board a vessel. O’Donnell believes that would defeat the purpose of ACP, which is supposed to reduce duplicated efforts.

As with other witnesses, O’Donnell was also asked to use his expertise to help investigators interpret some of the information that was captured on El Faro’s Voyage Data Recorder, or black box. O’Donnell was invited by the NTSB to be a part of the team that transcribed the VDR.

Specifically, O’Donnell was asked- in his experience- if there is any potential concerns with a steam boiler in a flooding situation.

“If the boiler was hot and it was shocked with cold water, it could possibly have had a catastrophic failure, boiler explosion maybe,” O’Donnell says.

He says, based on his knowledge in the industry and the crew conversations, he believes the engine room was busy, but facing significant challenges.

“If the vessel was inclined and they couldn’t get lube oil pressure, they would have needed lube oil pressure to be able to open the throttles to get propulsion on the vessel,” he says.

El Faro had lost propulsion before sinking in Hurricane Joaquin, and the VDR captured the Captain saying they “lost the plant”. We know the ship had taken on water and was listing, with investigators hearing a report earlier this week about the “likely” series of events that led to the ship going down.

WOKV continues to follow the latest from the MBI. Get continued updates on Twitter.

Read More

The Latest News Headlines

  • On a day when Americans honor veterans, a Florida man got a double treat -- a parade to honor his military service and his 90th birthday, which fell on Memorial Day this year. Vincent Delmore, who served in the U.S. Army Air Corps, was expecting a quiet birthday since most of his family lives in his native Connecticut, the Naples Daily News reported. Family and friends had different ideas, organizing a parade of patrol cars and friends through his neighborhood. Family members showed up, too. “It was a complete surprise,” Delmore told the Daily News in a telephone call. “I don’t know how many (patrol) cars there were with lights on.” Family members living in Tampa and Orlando made the drive to southwest Florida to visit. It was exciting for the 90-year-old man, who joked about his age to the Daily News. “Make sure not to put my picture in the obituary section,” he told the newspaper.
  • QUICK FACTS:  On a rainy Memorial Day, some families would have considered the movie theater for entertainment. But in Florida, movies theaters cannot fully reopen yet.  A Jacksonville movie theater, Sun-Ray Cinema in Five Points, is offering a new program to continue serving guests.  Watch the video below to learn about the program that allows for a controlled environment, social distancing and entertainment with family and friends.
  • A UPS driver made an Oklahoma woman’s Memorial Day weekend when he delivered a package to her home in Mayes County. Video from Chelsie Ashley’s front door in Adair shows the driver deliver her a package and notice her American flag, displayed on the front of her home, had rolled up in the wind. The driver stopped on his way off her porch to unravel it, leaving it flowing right through the breeze again. Ashley said she was getting ready for the day and checked the app on her phone to see who was at her door as he was leaving. “He didn’t know anyone was watching him, but he just did it just to do it,' Ashley told KOKI-TV. “I thought it was so cool what he was doing when no one was looking.' Ashley told KOKI it was important to have something uplifting and positive right now, and shared the video on her Facebook page.
  • The annual Memorial Day observance at the Jacksonville National Cemetery gives families the chance to pay tribute to their fallen heroes. The ceremony looked a lot different this year because of COVID-19.  Valerie Burks was among hundreds who came to the cemetery to honor those who made the ultimate sacrifice.  “This is a special day for us just to thank them,” said Burks.  The day holds a special meaning for her family. Her son Samuel L. Banks who served in the U.S. Army died in 2006.  “It’s been over six years; my son was 29 when he died of leukemia and he had done two tours in Iraq,” Burks added.  For many who served this holiday is personal.  “Sometimes the masks are getting wet because of tears so a lot of emotions being showed,” said U.S. Army veteran Roosevelt Knight Jr.  “This is something that we all should get out and support and continue to support,” explained Navy veteran Ace Wright.  Burks says military service is what her son wanted to do  “He was a very dedicated father and loved the military,” Burks said.  Now in the years after his death, she still carries his picture in her phone.  “He was tall and a very big guy. He loved momma’s cooking,” said Burks.  The flyover that was supposed to happen Monday afternoon got canceled because of the weather.
  • An appointment to get stimulus money from the City of Jacksonville, but no one to help. That’s what several people ran into Monday when they were scheduled to pick up their money, but did not know they had to reschedule because of the Memorial Day holiday.  To get the stimulus money, there is a process people have to go through. The preloaded card can be picked up by appointment only.  People like Cher Jamison are frustrated they were allowed to make an appointment on a holiday when everything is closed.  “I’m in line with about eight other people, nobody is here. Call the library, but nobody is answering because it’s a holiday,” Jamison said while standing in the rain.  Bernando Santana, who waited Monday morning, discovered an email from Sunday to reschedule when it was too late.  “An email the day before, and on a Sunday. I don’t check my emails on the weekend,” Santana said.  Santana and Jamison made their appointments weeks ago. They were given a confirmation to show up at 10 a.m. on Memorial Day.  They were instructed to go to the Ed Ball Building, but there was a sign on that door instructing people to go to the library.  Action News Jax reached out to the city to ask why these appointments were made in the first place and to ask if any emails were sent before the 24th.  “The city expects you to do your part, but they didn’t really go out of their way as far as I’m concerned,” Jamison said.

The Latest News Videos