ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

rain-day
79°
Sct Thunderstorms
H 86° L 77°
  • rain-day
    79°
    Current Conditions
    Sct Thunderstorms. H 86° L 77°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    84°
    Afternoon
    Sct Thunderstorms. H 86° L 77°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    81°
    Evening
    Sct Thunderstorms. H 86° L 77°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
The decision to scrap El Faro's sister ship
Close

The decision to scrap El Faro's sister ship

The decision to scrap El Faro's sister ship
El Faro's sister ship, El Yunque.

The decision to scrap El Faro's sister ship

El Faro’s sister ship was scrapped for “commercial reasons”, according to the company over the vessel.

Through this latest hearing session of the Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation working the El Faro sinking, consistent questions have arisen regarding some of the potential issues on board El Yunque, specifically in connection to her vent trunks. This session was also the first that investigators publicly confirmed El Yunque was being scrapped instead of heading to the Alaskan trade, but until Monday’s testimony, it wasn’t clear what went in to that decision.

TOTE attorneys questioning TOTE Maritime Puerto Rico Director of Operations Lee Peterson, who was the TOTE Services Director of Safety and Marine Operations at the time of the sinking, asked him to point blank speak to whether the Coast Guard had ordered the ship be scrapped because of safety concerns.

“The decision on scrapping the El Yunque- I was not involved in that decision, but my understanding is that it was a commercial decision and it was based on the conversions that were ongoing with the Orca class ships,” Peterson says.

El Faro and El Yunque were set to be converted for the Alaskan trade in order to temporarily take the place of two Orca-class ships on that route, which were thought to need engine replacements, according to Peterson. He says the new engines were to meet new emissions standards, and would take the ships out of service, at a foreign shipyard, for an extended period of time.

FULL COVERAGE: El Faro sinking

The engine manufacturer later determined the engines could be converted, instead of replaced.

“The current conversion, a lot of it can be done underway on the vessels. And for the required shipyard periods, they’re a short enough duration where we don’t require a replacement ship to fill in for them,” Peterson says.

As a result, he says they no longer needed El Yunque to spell the Alaska ships. His attorney asked whether he was aware of conversations of other commercial factors that also went in to the decision to scrap, but Peterson says he was not.

The MBI wanted to be explicitly clear, though.

“Is it your testimony that the El Yunque was not scrapped at least in part due to safety concerns that would have to be corrected and the substantial amount of work to be done,” asked MBI Chair Captain Jason Neubauer.

Peterson initially responded “correct”, before consulting with his attorney and stating that he wasn’t aware of any safety considerations in the decision. TOTE Services Attorney Luke Reid soon added a caveat, though.

“He gave you what his understanding was with respect to the reason, and it involved Orcas and thinks like that in his testimony. Sitting down with Mr. Peterson, we realized that that was not a correct statement. So his understanding was not correct, I just wanted to make sure that’s corrected for the record,” Reid says.

The clear line was blurred further, when some on the MBI introduced glimpses of conversations or correspondences they appeared to question could be involved in the decision. Board Member Keith Fawcett asked Peterson if he was aware of discussions in September 2015 related to delaying the Orca conversions because of a “cascading series of events”, which included problems with the Isla Bella. The Isla Bella is one of the ships that was going to replace El Faro and El Yunque, who were then going to spell the Alaskan ships. Neubauer further asked whether Peterson was aware of a meeting between senior TOTE executives and the US Coast Guard headquarters to discuss the scrapping of El Yunque.

On both accounts, Peterson was not aware of the conversations.

GALLERY: Inside the MBI third hearing session

Through this hearing session, the MBI Board has been closely examining specifically the state of El Yunque’s vent trunks. Earlier testimony shows there was severe wastage found in one of the trunks in 3 hold during a Document of Compliance Audit. The Coast Guard says the American Bureau of Shipping was tasked with inspecting the other vent trunks, and they cleared them. During a later drydock on the Northwest, though, wastage was found by the Coast Guard in many other trunks, and inspectors believed it to be long term.

TOTE Services Port Engineer Tim Neeson tells the MBI he was involved in the inspection of the other vent trunks, after the ship had been moved to the drydock.  He crawled inside and chipped at the metal to determine the strength and state.

“Pretty bad, pretty rusty,” Neeson says.

He says they opened “a considerable amount” of the vent trunks, but not all of them.

They made a plan to address the needed repairs, which included changing questionable steel. Plans changed with the decision to scrap the vessel.

There has been no documentation of severe wastage found on El Faro at this time, but investigators have noted that they will continue to present evidence connected to her sister ship because of the similarities and because it can help speak to how the vessels were being managed. The vent trunks specifically have also become a point of interest, since an MBI-requested report presented during this hearing session showed it’s possible water was able to get in through the vent trunks, contributing to the flooding El Faro was experiencing ahead of her sinking.

WOKV continues to follow the latest from the MBI. Get instant updates on Twitter.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • An explosion at an Army depot in Pennsylvania left at least three people injured Thursday morning, according to multiple reports.  >> Read more trending news Officials at Letterkenny Army Depot confirmed Thursday morning that an explosion happened in an industrial area of Building 350. “The incident is contained and will not affect depot operations or workforce safety elsewhere,” officials said in the statement. “There were injuries that fire and emergency services have treated and individuals have been transported to medical facilities.” The incident was reported around 7:15 a.m., according to WPMT. In a Facebook post, officials with the volunteer Franklin Fire Company said they responded Thursday morning to an “explosion with burn victims” at Letterkenny. The Franklin County Office of Emergency Management told Fox News three people were flown from the Army depot after the blast. Check back for updates to this developing story.
  • Eight animals have died after a jaguar escaped from its habitat at the Audubon Zoo in New Orleans and the whole event has caught the attention of Dan Maloney, Deputy Director of Animal Care and Conservation at the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens.  “I think we’re all standing up and taking notice,” Maloney tells WOKV.  A little background, Maloney was the General Curator at the exact zoo for 10 years but worked at the zoo for 12 years. He was there when the Audubon Zoo opened the Jaguar Jungle exhibit and helped designed it which is why he says this event has a big impact on him. He has since reached out to the zoo and offered his support.  Maloney says the similarities between the Range of the Jaguar JZG and Jaguar Jungle is that they both have woven mesh areas. While it’s not exactly clear how the Jaguar in New Orleans escaped, Maloney says JZG has been keeping a cautious eye on the Jaguars’ habitat.  “We have never seen any inclination for our Jaguars to look at the mesh.” Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens will be looking at the connection points with its mesh to make sure that it is sound and there is no degrading or rusting. Another thing Maloney points out is that the zoo has cameras all over the exhibit to monitor animal behavior.  “We never have detected the Jaguars working on the mesh at all, starting to bite at it or doing any of those kind of things.”  Maloney says if the zoo detects anything out of the ordinary in the Range of Jaguar he will reach out to WOKV.
  • A steam pipe explosion in Manhattan’s Flatiron District sent massive plumes into the sky Thursday morning over New York City. >> Watch WABC’s coverage here According to WNBC, the blast occurred about 6:30 a.m. EDT Thursday near the intersection of 21st Street and Fifth Avenue. >> Read more trending news  Authorities have not reported any injuries in the explosion, which “spewed debris all over the streets,” the news station said. Fire crews were still at the scene an hour later, and officials closed streets in the area as commuters headed to work. 
  • “I think he’s been pretty lucky,” Zane mom says as she reflects on the months-long journey they had to go through as a family as Zane battles cancer.  She says Zane was normal for the most part, but he kept getting different types of respiratory infections.  “We had begged our doctor to let us see a specialist and they finally did. And the day before he came up to us and was like, ‘what is this?’ and there was a lump coming out the side of his stomach.” That’s when their lives changed, the tests started and then they found it…Wilms Tumor stage three. Zane’s family says there were times when things were difficult but thanks having an amazing support system who they were able to reach out to in times of need.  “There are a lot of days where its just rough. Just make sure that you have a good support system and there’s families here that would be happy to reach out to you.” Zane had surgery not too long after his diagnosis and then went on to undergoing chemotherapy and radiation. He did have some side effects from the radiation like nausea, but his family says he has been doing fairly well. His family says they can see the finish line because Zane is almost done with chemo now.   Zane says he’s feeling good especially after having a good port access and says he’s looking forward to being both a scuba diver and police officer when he grows up. 
  • Police in Natchitoches, Louisiana, are searching for those responsible for killing a baby Monday night in a horrendous act of brutality. >> Read more trending news  Authorities were called to a trailer park just after 9 p.m. over a missing 6-month-old infant, who had disappeared from his home after two strangers showed up at the door, according to KSLA-TV. Police said a woman at the residence opened her door and was sprayed in the face with an unknown substance. KSLA reported the woman ran from the attackers and when she returned, the baby was gone. Just over an hour later, investigators responded to a call about a fire and found a baby with “obvious burns over his body,” according to the news station. >> Related: DNA test solves 1988 cold case rape, murder of 8-year-old April Tinsley, suspect arrested The baby later died from his injuries. Police are still investigating and haven’t made any arrests. 

The Latest News Videos