ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day
63°
Rain
H 73° L 63°
  • cloudy-day
    63°
    Current Conditions
    Rain. H 73° L 63°
  • rain-day
    65°
    Morning
    Rain. H 73° L 63°
  • rain-day
    66°
    Afternoon
    Rain. H 67° L 60°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
El Faro crew was fatigued, inconsistently evaluated ahead of final voyage
Close

El Faro crew was fatigued, inconsistently evaluated ahead of final voyage

El Faro crew was fatigued, inconsistently evaluated ahead of final voyage
Photo Credit: Stephanie Brown

El Faro crew was fatigued, inconsistently evaluated ahead of final voyage

As part of the NTSB’s investigation of the sinking of El Faro, several groups were formed to examine specific factors, like engineering, meteorology, and more. 

Now, the Human Factors Group Chairman’s Factual Report has been released, focusing on many different aspects of personnel on and off the ship, including company oversight and training.   

FULL COVERAGE: The sinking of El Faro

El Faro went down in Hurricane Joaquin in October 2015, while heavily loaded and transiting from Jacksonville to Puerto Rico. All 33 people on board the cargo ship died. The NTSB participated in a series of Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation hearings to publicly question interested parties and vet evidence, but also conducted their own interviews. Both Boards are now working separately to put forward their full investigative findings, with the NTSB’s expected out later this year. 

As part of their ongoing investigation, the NTSB released several factual reports late last year. WOKV has taken a comprehensive look in to each one. 

Voyage Data Recorder Group Chairman’s Factual Report: Captain altered course twice, but denied two more changes recommended by crew

Engineering Group Chairman’s Factual Report: Boiler components were recommended for service, plant failed on final voyage

Electronic Data Group Chairman’s Factual Report: Gaps seen in weather data downloads, but cause unclear

Survival Factors Group Chairman’s Report: Open lifeboats allowed because of El Faro’s age, both were badly damaged with nobody on board

Meteorology Group Chairman’s Factual Report: Challenging storm led to substantial forecast track errors

This latest Report comes soon after four newly transcribed portions from El Faro’s Voyage Data Recorder- or black box- were released. The overall VDR transcription is the longest ever assembled by the NTSB, capturing more than 26 hours of audio and data leading up to the sinking.   

Credentialing, training, and evaluating the crew 

The Report says El Faro’s officers were all trained in compliance with Coast Guard and International Maritime Organization regulations, but the company managing the crewing- TOTE- did not require formal heavy-weather training courses because the Coast Guard didn’t require them. The Report says, since 2003, masters and chief mates have had to takes exams covering some aspects of heavy weather to get their credentials, but El Faro’s master got his before and was grandfathered in without needing to test those criteria. 

TOTE says informal heavy-weather training took place. The company did not have anyone dedicated to ship-specific training and records, rather that was overseen by various shoreside personnel, ship masters, and individual mariners. 

Senior officers on the ships were required to get annual performance reviews, and other officers and crew got evaluations at the end of each ten-week rotation or if they detached from a ship, according to TOTE policy. The investigation so far has found these were not always done on schedule, though. In fact, the second mate’s most recent evaluation was November 2011, and only incomplete draft evaluations were found for the captain and chief engineer. 

The Report goes in to detail on the performance evaluations on record for El Faro’s officers. By and large, the reviews show high marks. 

GALLERY: Tributes to the El Faro crew

The captain’s most recent evaluation was considered to be a draft by TOTE, and was partially completed October 2014. The port engineer scored the captain excellent- the highest mark- in all categories, except for “cooperation with technical manager”, which was blank. Comments on the evaluation included praise for the captain’s professionalism, saying that he “handles a diversified and unpredictable crew quite well”. This evaluation had not been signed by the captain or technical manager, nor had it been stamped by TOTE for formal receipt. 

The second mate’s most recent evaluation in her performance file was from November 2011, when she was a third mate. At that time, the evaluator said the company should aim to keep her long term. There was no performance evaluation in her file from her time as second mate. 

The chief engineer’s most recent evaluation on file was also from when he served a different role- first assistance engineer in July 2013. At that time, he got high scores, with comments about his good attitude and work ethic. There was a draft evaluation from October 2014 which dealt with him as a chief engineer and a partially complete evaluation from the same year, but it was not stamped for formal receipt. 

This chief mate was hailed as passionate and a good instructor. The third mate was a solid watch stander who had the knowledge and skills to advance. The first assistant engineer was marked “fair” in attention to duty, but was also on his first trip in a newly raised role. The second assistant engineer was praised as “one of the most dependable and hardest working men”. Third assistant engineer number one was valuable and highly reliable, number two was recommended in November 2014 to get better knowledge of the ship and equipment, and number three was new to the company- he joined El Faro the evening they left on what would become the final voyage.     

New position assignments 

At the time of El Faro’s final voyage, TOTE was heavily involved in launching new LNG ships to replace El Faro and her sister vessel on the Jacksonville-Puerto Rico route. Testimony and records examined by investigators show those decisions were causing hostility on board and leaving El Faro’s captain specifically questioning where he stood. 

For the first time, this Report shows El Faro captain’s prior employer- for whom he worked for a few years leading up to 2013- had raised some concerns about him. NTSB investigators requested his performance evaluations and related materials for the most recent two years, and found two letters of warning and a letter detailing a meeting between the captain and management. 

The Report says that meeting included discussing overtime for cargo operations, concern of unprofessional or disparaging remarks to non-vessel personnel by vessel officers, perception of the captain disassociating himself from daily activities, and perception of disharmony between the master and senior officers. One letter of warning listed two violations on accident reporting. 

“Any further incidents of policy infractions or poor job performance would cause us to have a loss of confidence in you as master within our fleet of vessels,” the letter says, according to the Report. 

The other warning letter said the captain failed to notify management of cargo damage. That letter stated that the captain had already been warned more severe disciplinary action could be coming, including termination. The captain submitted his letter of resignation in the month that followed that letter. 

Correspondence from TOTE officials who were vetting the captain to potentially lead one of the new LNG vessels also showed concerns about the captain’s performance. Emails read during the public hearings show one official had “dwindling confidence” in the captain, and another described him as a “stateroom Captain”- although he later testified that was a stylistic difference, but that he was still an “effective” captain. 

Emails show the captain received a verbal warning from TOTE for welding repairs that weren’t carried out, but there were no letters of warning or reprimand on his file with that company. 

GALLERY: NTSB Factual Reports exhibits

The crewing decisions were causing friction on board, according to the testimony of off-duty crew and crew spouses. None of TOTE’s captains were selected for the new vessels at the time, although El Faro’s captain was later brought in for another interview for reconsideration, and it was decided he would be offered the job. Before the captain was informed of that decision, though, TOTE learned about an incident involving a potential violation of the company’s no-tolerance alcohol policy by an El Faro crew member, but it was not well documented. The company postponed their final decision on the new vessel, and communications from the captain in the days before the sinking indicate he still didn’t have a clear picture what would happen. 

The captain himself indicated in communications that he had also not gotten any information from TOTE on why he wasn’t chosen for a new vessel on the first pass, and he believed he was improving the culture on TOTE vessels- including helping a ship after drug and Customs issues. There was conflicting testimony whether El Faro’s captain would have been asked to stay on with the vessel when it transitioned to the Alaskan trade, as planned. 

There was also friction among the rest of the crew over the decisions about the new vessels. While there were non-disclosure agreements for those selected for the new ships, testimony from some crew members showed there was discontent among those who were not selected.     

Corporate responsibilities 

El Faro was owned by TOTE Maritime Puerto Rico and operated by TOTE Services- both under the umbrella of TOTE Inc. 

TMPR was previously Sea Star Line, and during a reorganization under that name in 2012-2013, there were some positions that were cut, including port captains. Port captains used to oversee vessel operations along with the port engineer. Another part of the reorganization included relocating more personnel to Jacksonville. 

TOTE testified that the reorganization didn’t have a negative impact on the shoreside support they provided to ships, but the Report notes there was some conflicting testimony from others about the actual implications. 

The Report says TOTE had considered hiring more employees to specifically assist the Manager of Safety and Operations because of his “extensive duties”, but that didn’t happen ahead of the sinking, and that person continued to carry all of the work. By early 2017, testimony showed some of the responsibilities had been reallocated across other existing employees. The Director of Marine Safety and Services also testified that his time was increasingly focused on TOTE’s new LNG ships, and there was no formal reassignment of the other responsibilities on his plate. 

AUDIO: El Faro’s captain describes marine emergency in final shoreside contact

When El Faro was in distress and later determined to have sunk, but the search for possible survivors was still ongoing, there was an emergency response team stood up. The Report notes testimony from the Vice President of Marine Operations- who was on that team- saying he didn’t know the specific duties of the members of the team. The emergency response team would run scenarios as practice, but none specific to heavy weather, according to NTSB interviews with team members. 

While the phone number for the Designate Person- a TOTE official available at all hours for any emergencies or needs on the ship- was posted throughout the ship per the Safety Management System, the only company-provided phone on board was on the bridge. That led to questions in the public hearings about whether safety concerns on board could truly be reported anonymously- since there were always people on watch on the bridge. 

There was also an online reporting tool, with information posted on the ship, although an internet connection would be required to use the site. Crew were also not prohibited from having their own cell phones, but connection would be difficult at sea.     

Safety on board 

TOTE- like other shipping companies- is required to have a safety management system that defines the responsibilities of personnel, safe practice for ship operation, and safeguards against certain risks. 

Internal audits of the SMS and International Safety Management code were required at least every 12 months, to be completed by TOTE’s Designated Person. External audits also took place by the ship’s surveyor, the American Bureau of Shipping. El Faro’s most recent internal audit was submitted to the company in June 2015. The DP says he was satisfied the crew knew the SMS, and the SMS itself appeared to be well implemented and documented. 

Investigators also reviewed minutes from safety meetings that took place on board. The SMS required monthly safety and security meetings on the ship, and El Faro’s most recent was toward the end of September 2015. 

Two human factors influencing safety on board are pace of operations and crew fatigue. 

TOTE’s competitor, Horizon Lines, downsized in 2012 and completely stopped operations on the Jacksonville-Puerto Rico route in late 2014. TOTE picked up more business as a result, and used barges to supplement the existing ships to carry the increased volume of cargo. Turnover notes showed the cargo load on board was “continually heavy”, according to the Report. 

The Report says El Faro’s captain was known to be able to maintain his schedule, even though TOTE says ship personnel didn’t know that was something they tracked. There was also testimony from a few different sources saying the company didn’t pressure the crew to keep to arrival times, although a company official admitted in testimony that the owners would get incentives for keeping the ships on schedule. 

GALLERY: El Faro’s Voyage Data Recorder recovered

The Report says El Faro’s officers were under contract to work 12 hours a day while on the vessel. While the hours for the sinking voyage aren’t available because they were on board, records for two two-week periods just ahead of the sinking show officers logging on average 13 hour days and 12.5 hour days. SIU crew members worked an average of 10.9 hour- and 13 hour-work days in those same time frames, with the Report indicating they were on overtime past an eight hour day. 

The captain was required to track work and rest hours to ensure they were in compliance with regulations. Testimony was unclear on who in the company would then further verify, although the Designated Person said every crew member was also responsible for tracking themselves. 

The mates would generally get a little relief in port, when a port mate would help oversee cargo loading operations. Records show a port mate was not used in Jacksonville in the final days of El Faro, though. Work/rest records for El Faro’s third mate show four violations in the final two months. 

“The chief engineer told his wife that he was exhausted from all the maintenance and issues he had in the weeks leading to the accident, stating that it was the worst tour he had been on in terms of maintenance issues,” says the Report, citing an interview done with the chief engineer’s wife. 

Interviews with friends of the second mate showed she also complained of fatigue and used over-the-counter medication to help get sleep. Testimony and the VDR transcript also spoke about a former chief mate who had fallen asleep while on watch. Further, the captain had worked a normal ten-week shift that ended July 14th, but was called back after only four weeks off because his relief had resigned.   

Operating in severe weather 

El Faro used the Bon Voyage System as one of their primary weather systems. The system would map weather conditions along with sea conditions, for a ship to use as guidance for routing. The investigation in to the sinking so far has shown a one-time glitch in BVS led to an outdated forecast track being sent to El Faro on their final voyage, but the larger questions that have emerged include whether all of those who needed to use the system were fully trained and if anyone other than the captain could access all of the needed information. 

The Report says there is no evidence BVS users on El Faro had any formal training. Rather, prior deck officers who testified said training was on the job, with manuals and guides readily available. 

The captain was heard on El Faro’s VDR expressing some difficulty with the consistently changing track of Joaquin, although he also stated he believed they would just get around it. The captain did also make some course changes on the fatal voyage, in an effort to ensure they would skirt the storm. 

The BVS system sent the data packages to the captain’s stateroom, and he had to download it to send to the bridge, according to the Report. This addresses another frequent question from investigators during the hearings, which is whether the crew was able to get this information directly on the bridge, even without the captain- it appears that was not the case. While the Report says most data packets were downloaded and sent to the bridge by the captain within an hour of them being received, the packet sent to the ship at 11PM the night ahead of the sinking wasn’t downloaded for five hours and 41 minutes, or 4:45AM the morning of the sinking 

TOTE’s SMS did not have many specific procedures for heavy weather, except that the ship’s master monitor and analyze weather along the ship’s track and take proper precautions. Additionally, the chief mate needed to ensure watertight hatches and doors were secure, but there was no outline on how that would be verified, according to the Report. 

GALLERY: El Faro’s wreckage

If the captain needed to slow the ship’s speed or change course because of weather, he was required to tell company headquarters. There was an email from El Faro’s captain shown during the public hearings that indicated he was seeking approval to change his route on what would have been the return trip on the fatal voyage, rather than just informing the company of the change. Several TOTE officials repeatedly testified to investigators that permission was not needed, and they were unsure why the captain would have sought it. Rather, they said the captain was empowered to make decisions about voyage planning and vessel operations. There were additionally other communications presented which showed the captain informing TOTE of changes as a “professional courtesy”, and even in the email where he appears to seek permission to take an alternate return route, he also told the company he had adjusted his immediate route further to the south to try to get around the storm. 

There were no alerts from the company sent about the system that developed in to Hurricane Joaquin, or Tropical Storm Erika before that. TOTE had sent vessels a safety alert about Hurricane Danny earlier that summer, but told investigators the intent there was as a general advisory about the start of the hurricane season and need to review heavy weather procedures. 

During Erika, the Report says a TOTE Maritime Puerto Rico employee in Jacksonville did send an email to some shoreside personnel and three captains with details on the Coast Guard preparations for a port closure. A captain later replied some of the steps he was taking because of the storm, and the next day the Designated Person asked the captain for a detailed list of preparedness/avoidance plans and daily updates. The Report says there was no such initial contact or follow up request made during El Faro’s final voyage, but the ship’s captain did send his avoidance strategy to shoreside staff. 

Nobody in TOTE was specifically assigned to monitor ships while at sea.   

Polish riding gang 

Part of the SMS includes that all members of a riding gang are given a full tour of the vessel. El Faro had a Polish riding gang on board on her final voyage, working specifically on preparing the ship to convert to the Alaska trade. 

The training logs associated with the riding gang were on El Faro, so not available for the investigation. A Polish worker who was on the ship in the weeks ahead of the final voyage did tell investigators that they immediately went to the captain’s office to fill out forms after boarding the ship, and they did get a tour. He did not remember any safety briefing, had not been taken to the lifeboats to see what to do in an emergency, had not put on a lifejacket while on board, and did not know what the ship’s emergency signals were. He further testified that the Polish riding gang didn’t participate in drills, and instead, kept working. Statements from wives of some of the Polish riding gang further reinforced that they did not go through safety training. 

The wives did say the gang thought highly of the off-duty chief engineer who was assigned as their supervisor. 

There were no orientation documents or safety signage provided in the Polish language, and there was substantial testimony that showed most of the workers who had cycled through spoke little or no English- although the Report notes it’s not clear about the fluency of the workers on the final voyage specifically. One of the workers would act as the unofficial interpreter, according to testimony. 

“It is not clear whether the Polish riding gang understood the safety procedures,” the Report says. 

Wives of some of the Polish riding gang members also gave more insight of the conditions on the ship. 

“You can’t even imagine this old rust bucket I have to board,” one of the workers said, according to a transcript of an interview with his wife.   

Looking ahead 

The NTSB is expecting to release two more factual reports in the coming weeks- the Nautical Operations Group Factual Report and Naval Architecture Factual Report. WOKV will continue to work through the new information and add context from the ongoing investigations, as those documents are released. 

NTSB INVESTIGATION: Factual reports examine aspects of ship operations and sinking

The NTSB has already issued ten safety recommendations as a result of their work so far, saying they didn’t want to wait until completion because of the start of hurricane season. The recommendations encourage action on a few ket areas in order to improve the safety of mariners at sea.

The full NTSB report is expected out later this year.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • On Wednesday family friends and Nassau County law-enforcement gather to honor fallen Nassau County deputy Eric Oliver on the anniversary of his death. Oliver was hit and killed by a vehicle while chasing a suspect across State Road 200 on November 22, 2016. The Nassau County sheriffs office unveiled a memorial Wednesday at the gate gas station where the foot chase began.  Oliver has been recognized locally and nationally. His family told Action News Jax the community support has helped them grieve.  'It'll be there forever and I think it just represents the lawn enforcement in the community and the sacrifice they make,' Deputy Oliver's mother Sharon says of the memorial. 
  • A Jacksonville man is in jail, accused of burglarizing three homes he was hired to fix up after Hurricane Irma. The vacation rental homes were all on Ponte Vedra Boulevard in Ponte Vedra Beach. All three homes are owned by Vacation Quest. The company told the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office it hired Kyle Best to “board up and clean up damaged vacation rental homes after Hurricane Irma.” At 5:30 on CBS47 @ActionNewsJax: #Jacksonville man accused of burglarizing 3 homes in #PonteVedraBeach that he was hired to fix up after Hurricane #Irma pic.twitter.com/sLmK8oqTlq — Jenna Bourne (@jennaANjax) November 22, 2017 “It’s distressing to say the least, but I really feel sorry for the homeowners, because they’ve already had a really hard blow with the storm,” said Esther Nichols, who is renting out a vacation home a few doors down from one of the burglarized homes. Best’s arrest reports say he pawned multiple televisions in Jacksonville. A man working in the garage of one of the burglarized rentals on Wednesday identified himself as Vacation Quest leadership. He did not want to go on camera, but said he’s glad Best was caught. Best’s arrest reports say he denied being involved with the burglaries, and claimed another man who was also hired to clean up those vacation homes asked him to pawn the televisions. The St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office told Action News Jax that man is Julian Cortez, who has two outstanding warrants for the crime, but has not been arrested. Best is being held on $60,000 bond.
  • Three Indiana men and a woman have been booked on more than 30 separate criminal charges in connection with the alleged beating and kidnapping of a married lesbian couple. One of the men, Kenneth Allen Braswell, 32, is charged with raping one of the women, according to Indianapolis jail records. Braswell is also charged with criminal confinement, kidnapping, battery with a deadly weapon, battery resulting in bodily injury and unlawful possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. Police have charged Jose Antonio Nieves, 35, and Thomas James Bell, 26, with crimes that include kidnapping, criminal confinement, battery, intimidation, possession of meth and carrying a handgun without a license. Melissa Richards, 29, is charged with multiple counts of criminal confinement and battery. >> Read more trending news The Indianapolis Star reported that an affidavit filed in the case states the couple traveled from Terre Haute to a home on the east side of Indianapolis the morning of Nov. 10 to do heroin. Fox 59 in Indianapolis reported that the house was Richards’ home.  One of the women borrowed Richards’ Mustang to visit her son about 20 miles away in Danville, the news station reported. The women said that Richards became angry when the car wasn’t returned quickly enough.  “I’m keeping your wife until I get my car back,” Richards said, according to the affidavit.  The woman still at Richards’ house told police she was bound with duct tape, pistol-whipped and left in a large closet, the Star reported. She said that, at some point, she felt someone pulling her pants down. The woman told detectives that Braswell raped her, the Star said.  “If you scream, I’ll hurt you,” he told her, according to the affidavit.  The woman said that her captors then took her to the basement, where she was beaten some more, Fox 59 reported. On Nov. 11, some of the accused retrieved the Mustang, along with the wife, who they forced to go with them at gunpoint, the affidavit said.  When they got back to Richards’ house, the woman was placed in the basement with her wife, where she was also beaten, the document said.  The women said they were held in the basement until Nov. 14. They were given food and water once, but could not eat due to their injuries, police said.  The Star reported that the affidavit described bruises and cuts on both women’s faces. One of the women also had a broken collarbone.  One of the victims described watching as the group beat her wife, who fell to the ground. “I didn’t know if she was alive anymore,” the woman said, according to the affidavit.  On Nov. 14, Nieves and Bell are accused of putting both women in Richards’ Mustang for a drive to Bargersville, where, one woman told police, Nieves talked about killing them, the Star said. She said Nieves claimed he knew someone there who would help bury their bodies. On the way to Bargersville, the Mustang blew a tire, the Star reported. They pulled into a convenience store parking lot, where the women said Nieves tried injecting himself with heroin. The women asked to use the bathroom, the affidavit said. When Nieves allowed them to go inside the store, the women begged the clerk to call police. The women locked themselves in the bathroom until police arrived, the Star reported.  Nieves and Bell were arrested outside the convenience store, while Braswell and Richards were taken into custody at Richards’ home.  The Star said that detectives searching Richards’ home confiscated a bloody towel, along with bloody sweatpants found in the closet where one victim said she was raped. There was also a large pool of blood on the basement floor.  In the Mustang, they found two handguns, duct tape, a machete and two cellphones. Braswell, Nieves and Richards remained in the Marion County Jail on Wednesday. It was not immediately clear when Bell was released.  Court records show that Braswell, Nieves and Bell are scheduled for a Jan. 22 trial on the charges. 
  •   It’s almost go time. Sure, you have a turkey and all the fixins’ to fix, family to visit with and football to watch, but you also have sales to attend, deals to get and shopping to get over with. With holiday shopping barking at the door like a pack of wolves, here's a quick guide to the best deals, store hours, ads and shopping apps.  Good luck! Below is a list of store opening times for Thanksgiving: Bass Pro Shops – 8 a.m. Bealls Florida – 6 p.m. Belk – 4 p.m. Bergner’s – 11 a.m. Best Buy – 5 p.m. Big Lots - 7 a.m. Bon-Ton – 11 a.m. Boston Store – 11 a.m. Cabela’s – 8 a.m.  Carson’s – 11 a.m. Dick’s Sporting Goods – 6 p.m.  Dollar General – 7 a.m. Elder-Beerman – 11 a.m.  Five Below – 6 p.m.  Fred’s Pharmacy – 9 a.m. GameStop – 4 p.m. Herberger’s – 11 a.m. JCPenney – 2 p.m. Kohl’s – 5 p.m.  Kmart – 6 a.m. Macy’s – 5 p.m.  Meijer – 6 a.m. Michaels – 6 p.m. (Opens at 5 p.m. for Rewards members) Rite Aid – Hours Vary by Location (most stores open) Sears – 6 p.m.  Shopko – 4 p.m.  Stage Stores – 2 p.m. Target – 6 p.m.  Toys R Us – 5 p.m. Walgreens – Varies by Location Walmart – 6 p.m. (for Black Friday deals) Younker’s – 11 a.m. See the complete list of Thanksgiving openings/hours here. Below is a list of the store opening times for Black Friday: Babies R Us - 8 a.m. Bass Pro Shops - 5 a.m.   Belk - 6 a.m.  Best Buy - 8 a.m. Big Lots - 6 a.m. BJ's Wholesale Club - 7 a.m. Cabela's - 5 a.m. Costco - 9 a.m. Dick's Sporting Goods - 5 a.m. Guitar Center - 6 a.m. Hobby Lobby - 8 a.m. Home Depot 6 a.m. JCPenney - Thanksgiving 2 p.m. through Black Friday Kmart - 6 a.m. Kohl's - Thanksgiving 5 p.m. to Black Friday 1 p.m.  Lowe's - 6 a.m. Macy's - 6 a.m. to 1 p.m. Meijer - 6 a.m. Michaels - 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. Office Depot & OfficeMax - 7:45 a.m. PetSmart - 7 a.m. Sam's Club - 7 a.m. Sears - 5 a.m. to 2 p.m. Staples - 7 a.m. Target - 6 a.m. Toys R Us - Thanksgiving 5 p.m. to Black Friday 11 p.m. Walmart - Thanksgiving 6 p.m. overnight into Black Friday See the complete list of Black Friday 2017 hours here. Check out the ads Here is a list of some 'leaked' Black Friday ads from national retailers. (Click on the store name to see the Black Friday ad) Amazon.com Belk Best Buy Big Lots CVS JCPenney Kmart Kohls Macy's Michael's Old Navy Sam's Club Sears Stein Mart Target Walmart Black Friday best bets on TVs, laptops and tablets, electronics, smartphones and gaming Black Friday television deals From Amazon: Samsung UN65MU8000 65-inch 4K smart TV (2017 Model) for $1,297.99 (usually $2,199.99) From Amazon: Sony 70-inch 4K smart LED TV (2017 Model) for $1,199.99 (usually $1,498) From Best Buy: Samsung 65-inch 4K smart TV for $749.99 (usually $1,099.99) – Doorbuster From Best Buy: Samsung 50-inch 4K smart TV for $399.99 (usually $699.99) – Doorbuster From Best Buy: Samsung 65-inch 4K HDR smart TV for $1,297.99 (usually $1,499.99) From Best Buy: Sharp 60-inch 4K smart TV for $549.99 (usually $799.99) From Best Buy: Insignia 50-inch 4K smart TV with Roku for $349.99 (usually $449.99) From NewEgg: Samsung 50-inch 4K HDR smart TV for $424.99 (usually $547.99) From Sam’s Club: Vizio XLED Smartcast 65-inch Class 4K UHD HDR Home Theater Display for $598 From Target: Sharpe 55-inch 4K Smart UHD TV for $249.99 – Doorbuster  From Walmart: Sharp 55-inch Class 4K (2160P) Smart LED TV for $298 Black Friday laptop deals From Best Buy: Microsoft Surface Laptop (128GB SSD, Intel Core i5 processor, 4GB RAM) for $899  From Best Buy: Lenovo Yoga 710 (15.6-inch touchscreen, Intel Core i5 processor, 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD) for $599.99  From Staples: HP Pavilion desktop PC (Intel Core i5 Processor, 12GB RAM, 1TB HDD) for $369.99  From Staples: Dell 15.6-inch laptop (Intel Core i5 Processor, 8GB RAM, 1TB HD) for $419.99  From Costco: Dell XPS 13 QHD+ Touchscreen Laptop for $1,299.99 From HP: HP Envy x360 15-inch Laptop for $669.99 (usually $869.99) at HP From Dell: Inspiron 13 7000 Touch for $799.99  Doorbuster starting on 11/24 at 1 p.m. ET From Dell: Inspiron 15 5000 2-in-1 for $549.99 Doorbuster starting on 11/24 at 8 p.m. ET From NewEgg: Asus ROG G752VS (17.3-inch 1080p display with Nvidia G-Sync, 2.90 GHz seventh-gen Intel Core i7 processor, 16 GB RAM, 1 TB HDD, 512 GB SSD, Nvidia GTX 1070 GPU) for $1,779  From B&H: Apple 15.4-Inch MacBook Pro with Touch Bar (Late 2016, Silver) for $1,799  From B&H: Apple 21.5-inch iMac with Retina 4K Display (Mid 2017) for $1,179   Black Friday tablet deals From ebay: Apple iPad Pro 12.9' 128GB 4G+WIFI for $649.99  From Toys R Us: Nabi Barbie Kids Tablets for $39.99 From Sam’s Club: Samsung Galaxy 7.0' Tab E Lite for $69.86 From Amazon: Amazon Fire HD 10 for $99.99 From NewEgg: Refurbished Apple iPad 4 with 9.7' Retina Display for $149.99 From Staples: Samsung Galaxy Tab A-10.1” for $179.99'  Black Friday electronics deals From Walmart: Google Home Mini for $29 (plus a coupon worth up to $25 off your next Walmart order when linking your account to Google Express) From the Google Store: Google Home for $79 From the Google Store: Google Chromecast for $25  From Target: Google Wifi (three pack) for $249  From Best Buy: Google Chromecast Ultra for $54  Black Friday smartphone deals From Best Buy: Moto G Plus (5th Gen) 4G LTE with Motorola for $225 From Best Buy: Samsung Galaxy J7 4G LTE with Verizon for $100 From Target: iPhone SE for $100  From Target: iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus free with a $250 gift card with purchase  From T-Mobile: Buy one, get one free on the iPhone 8  From Sprint: Lease a Galaxy S8, S8 Plus, S8 Active, or Note 8 for 50 percent off From Motorola: Buy a Moto Z2 Play for $400  From Samsung: Buy a Galaxy S8 or Note 8, get a free Gear 360 Black Friday gaming deals From Best Buy: Madden 18 Xbox One S 500 GB bundle for $230, and as a bonus, you'll receive a free Xbox One controller.  From Microsoft: Xbox One S price for $189 From Walmart: PS4 for $199, and $39 DualShock 4 controllers From GameStop: Nintendo Switch for $300 From Costco: 1 TB PlayStation 4 bundle with Destiny 2 and Call of Duty: WWII for $290 From Walmart: Call of Duty: WWII for $43; Grand Theft Auto V for $29; Just Dance 2018 for $29  Apps for shopping Finding the best deals can be exhausting, but, as for most things in life nowadays, there’s an app for that. Actually a few of them. Here are a few suggestions that may help you with gift buying throughout the holiday season. Christmas Gift Planner in iTunes (called Christmas List in Android Market) You can see what you are spending in real time. It allows you to keeps lists of gifts purchased, the ones you are still looking for and whether the gift is wrapped. Gifts HD2 for iTunes and Android You can create lists, set budgets mark things off as you buy them, and add ideas as you go. It also allows you to comparison shop, which is great for Black Friday. No More Socks As with the other apps, No More Socks is a list-making and shopping app. In addition to searching retail sites, the app can also do a general Google search for products. Chameleon Chameleon will find the best price for an item and coupons if they are available. Chameleon works at more than 3,000 locations across the country. RedLaser RedLaser allows you to scan barcodes to find the best price, online or locally. PriceBlink A browser add-on, PriceBlink lets you know when there's a better price for a product you are shopping for online. Camel Camel Camel CamelCamelCamel is a site that tracks Amazon prices. It notifies you when the price drops on an item you've added to your Amazon shopping list.
  • A man impersonating a law enforcement officer pulled over a woman in Arkansas, according to the St. Francis County Sheriff’s Office. The incident happened Saturday on Highway 38 near Hughes. >> Read more trending news Investigators said a man impersonating a game and fish officer stopped a woman and asked to check her vehicle for guns. He had a blue light on his dash and was in a dark-colored pickup truck. The man did not show the woman a badge or a weapon. The incident happened during the daytime hours and appears to have been an isolated occurrence. Investigators said they believe they know who the man is, but no arrests were immediately made. Officials said the impersonator is not the same one who stopped people earlier this year.

The Latest News Videos