ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

Sponsored By: Two Men and a Truck
cloudy-day
77°
Cloudy
H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    77°
    Current Conditions
    Cloudy. H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    76°
    Morning
    Cloudy. H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    82°
    Afternoon
    Mostly Cloudy. H 84° L 76°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination
Close

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination
Photo Credit: Stephanie Brown

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination

As the new administration in Jacksonville prepares to take over, they’re given new insight in to a long running debate.

Mayor Alvin Brown requested several weeks ago that the Office of the General Counsel review local, state, and national laws dealing with protecting from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. On Brown’s last day in office, that 19 page study has been completed and released.

The OGC legal memorandum is not designed to be a policy opinion or directive, but rather an examination of the current protections- or lack thereof- on the books. While there have been no official plans released from any of the new City Councilmen to revisit a Human Rights Ordinance- like one which failed in 2012- it could be used as a reference on either reviving the debate or as part of the discussion.

It does highlight potential gaps and areas the City should consider moving forward.

Current protections and potential holes

Most of the memo focuses on outlining the protections which do exist at the local, state, and federal level. A lengthy review highlights federal anti-discrimination laws dealing with race, color, sex, religion, nationality, and more- even protections for pregnancy, disability, genetic information, and medical leave. The protection against discrimination applies, in varying levels, to wages, housing, employment, voting rights and other areas.

While the President issued an executive order prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, the memo notes this only applies to federal contractors and federal employees, and Congress has not acted to more broadly expand that.

The memo goes on to chronicle conflicting court opinions on whether discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity can be challenged under law that don’t appear to directly govern them- like a provision that extends protections based on “sex stereotypes”. The results of these challenges are largely mixed, according to OGC.

Laws at the state level are complicated- for this debate- by Florida’s expansion of religious freedom protections beyond what many other states have. The memo notes, for example, that in the failed 2012 HRO expansion in Jacksonville, there was an exception for religious freedom.

More broadly, race, color, age, disability, marital status and more are covered under Florida laws governing public accommodations, housing, and employment. A crime committed which targets people based on their sexual orientation is also classified as a hate crime in Florida, meaning the penalties would be more severe. While some companies choose to add specific protections for sexual orientation or gender identity, the OGC notes that Florida is one of 18 states which do not have any specific anti-discrimination laws for these areas.

Jacksonville’s prior fight

While the question has long laid below the surface, the issue of protecting against discrimination based on sexual identity or gender expression has become more prominent in Jacksonville over the past few years. Things hit a head in 2012 when the Council debated, and ultimately failed, to extend the City’s Human Rights Ordinance to also include “sexual orientation, gender identity, or expression”, or- a more narrow substitute- just sexual orientation.

“Jacksonville currently has no local laws explicitly prohibiting discrimination against the LGBT community,” the memo says.

Points to consider

OGC laid out several areas to consider if the issue of expanded anti-discrimination measures were to resurface.

First is the cost and liability the City could face under the expansion. The memo notes that a statewide study indicated the number of sexual orientation and gender identity related discrimination claims would not be projected to take a significant spike if new protections were added. The OGC took that one step further to say it would likely be a workload that can be absorbed by the investigating body that already operates over Jacksonville, the City’s Human Rights Commission.

The second consideration is the potentially symbolic weight the expansion would hold, in some cases just as significant as the binding legal effect itself. The memo cites a study which found just the presence of an official anti-discrimination policy may have been enough to raise awareness and lead potential discriminators- conscious or not about their actions- to reevaluate how they approach the situation.

Objections in prior debate from City Councilmen have included that protections already exist under current state and federal laws, so that may mean less of a need to add local protections. Putting aside the gaps noted in the memo, the OGC said the scope and how the potential new expansion would interact with state and federal laws is something that would have to be examined. Specifically, the new City protections would not be allowed to conflict with any established state or federal laws.

Finally, the OGC says the City must consider the ramifications any change in the anti-discrimination laws would have on Florida’s religious freedom legislation.

Moving forward

The OGC stressed that this memo is not a policy opinion, but a tool lawmakers can be used if- and likely when- this debate does surface once again. Ultimately, the memo makes it clear it’s up to the elected officials to determine “the best interests of the community they serve” and act from there.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • An 18-month-old boy died after a reported drowning at a Yulee home on Tuesday, officials said. The boy was taken to the hospital after the reported drowning on Lents Road near Roses Bluff Road at approximately 11 a.m. Nassau County Sheriff's Office deputies said the boy was in the care of his 15-year-old babysitter. He was in an above-ground pool outside a trailer, deputies said. His death is under investigation. No one has been charged at this point, deputies said.
  • The body of a woman found found Monday inside a bathroom at a Walmart in Oklahoma has been identified, but police still aren’t sure how long she was there. >> Read more trending news Sand Springs police have identified the woman as 29-year-old Katherine Caraway from Muskogee. According to police, employees assumed that the family bathroom was out of order because it was locked. Employees placed an out of order sign on the door Friday and it remained there throughout the weekend. On Monday, employees unlocked the bathroom door and found the woman.  Sand Springs Police say their preliminary investigation shows nothing suspicious about the woman's death. They do not know why she was in Sand Springs.  Walmart issued the following statement about the discovery:   'We are saddened by this. We don't know all the facts right now, but we are working closely with local law enforcement to provide what information we have that might be useful. Because this is an ongoing investigation, we must refer you to them for additional information.' 
  • A Middleburg man was arrested after witnesses say he pointed a bow and arrow at his neighbor's new boyfriend. That woman told Action News Jax she's frustrated law enforcement didn't take action sooner. 'He was always a very nice person, but he lost his mind,' she said. She asked not to be identified out of fear of retaliation. Gary Ruddlesden lives with his mother right around the corner from her. Clay County deputies arrested Ruddlesden after witnesses said he pointed a bow and arrow at the woman's new boyfriend after an argument through the fence. 'Bow and arrow sounds kind of like a kid thing, almost. But it's like a hunting bow and arrow,' she said. Ruddlesden's mother said her son just wanted to scare them, not hurt them. 'He's not a bad person,' said Ruddlesden's mother. Ruddlesden told his mother and friends that the woman is his ex-girlfriend, but she said they were just friends. Clay County Sheriff's Office records show the woman called deputies out to her home three times in the past month with complaints that Ruddlesden was harassing her. 'Since May 26, I've probably gotten over 300 texts. So when the police came out, you know, you try to point out the threatening ones - that he was going to kill my animals,' she said. The reports said deputies told her to block his number. She said she hopes this will be a wake-up call to law enforcement that they need to take women's complaints of harassment more seriously. Ruddlesden is charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon without intent to kill, a third-degree felony. He is being held on $15,000 bond. Although Ruddlesden has had a few run-ins with the law in the past, including pleading guilty to trafficking drugs, court records show this was his first time being arrested for a violent crime in Clay County.
  • A fireworks recall is underway just in time for the Fourth of July. >> Read more trending news TNT Fireworks is recalling Red White & Blue Smoke Fireworks, which were sold at Walmart, Target and other stores. The product can explode unexpectedly, according to the Consumer Product Safety Commission. “The Blue Ammo Smoke effect could rapidly dispel from the bottom of the tube in an explosive manner posing a burn hazard,” the company said on its website. The pyrotechnics were sold in four states, Ohio, Illinois, Vermont and Wisconsin, between May and this month. The company said it is offering a refund or a replacement for those who bought the defective fireworks.
  • Danish shipping conglomerate A.P. Moller-Maersk was one of multiple European companies to fall victim Tuesday to a cyberattack as Ukrainian government officials reported a “large-scale hacker attack” across the country. >> Read more trending news Attacks were also reported in several other countries, Russia cybersecurity firm Kaspersky Lab said in a statement, including the United States, Russia, Poland, Italy, the United Kingdom, Germany and France.

The Latest News Videos