ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

clear-day Created with Sketch.
56°
Clear
H 83° L 62°
  • clear-day Created with Sketch.
    56°
    Current Conditions
    Sunny. H 83° L 62°
  • clear-day Created with Sketch.
    79°
    Afternoon
    Sunny. H 83° L 62°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    76°
    Evening
    Partly Cloudy. H 83° L 62°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination
Close

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination
Photo Credit: Stephanie Brown

Jax OGC: no local laws prohibit LGBT discrimination

As the new administration in Jacksonville prepares to take over, they’re given new insight in to a long running debate.

Mayor Alvin Brown requested several weeks ago that the Office of the General Counsel review local, state, and national laws dealing with protecting from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. On Brown’s last day in office, that 19 page study has been completed and released.

The OGC legal memorandum is not designed to be a policy opinion or directive, but rather an examination of the current protections- or lack thereof- on the books. While there have been no official plans released from any of the new City Councilmen to revisit a Human Rights Ordinance- like one which failed in 2012- it could be used as a reference on either reviving the debate or as part of the discussion.

It does highlight potential gaps and areas the City should consider moving forward.

Current protections and potential holes

Most of the memo focuses on outlining the protections which do exist at the local, state, and federal level. A lengthy review highlights federal anti-discrimination laws dealing with race, color, sex, religion, nationality, and more- even protections for pregnancy, disability, genetic information, and medical leave. The protection against discrimination applies, in varying levels, to wages, housing, employment, voting rights and other areas.

While the President issued an executive order prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, the memo notes this only applies to federal contractors and federal employees, and Congress has not acted to more broadly expand that.

The memo goes on to chronicle conflicting court opinions on whether discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity can be challenged under law that don’t appear to directly govern them- like a provision that extends protections based on “sex stereotypes”. The results of these challenges are largely mixed, according to OGC.

Laws at the state level are complicated- for this debate- by Florida’s expansion of religious freedom protections beyond what many other states have. The memo notes, for example, that in the failed 2012 HRO expansion in Jacksonville, there was an exception for religious freedom.

More broadly, race, color, age, disability, marital status and more are covered under Florida laws governing public accommodations, housing, and employment. A crime committed which targets people based on their sexual orientation is also classified as a hate crime in Florida, meaning the penalties would be more severe. While some companies choose to add specific protections for sexual orientation or gender identity, the OGC notes that Florida is one of 18 states which do not have any specific anti-discrimination laws for these areas.

Jacksonville’s prior fight

While the question has long laid below the surface, the issue of protecting against discrimination based on sexual identity or gender expression has become more prominent in Jacksonville over the past few years. Things hit a head in 2012 when the Council debated, and ultimately failed, to extend the City’s Human Rights Ordinance to also include “sexual orientation, gender identity, or expression”, or- a more narrow substitute- just sexual orientation.

“Jacksonville currently has no local laws explicitly prohibiting discrimination against the LGBT community,” the memo says.

Points to consider

OGC laid out several areas to consider if the issue of expanded anti-discrimination measures were to resurface.

First is the cost and liability the City could face under the expansion. The memo notes that a statewide study indicated the number of sexual orientation and gender identity related discrimination claims would not be projected to take a significant spike if new protections were added. The OGC took that one step further to say it would likely be a workload that can be absorbed by the investigating body that already operates over Jacksonville, the City’s Human Rights Commission.

The second consideration is the potentially symbolic weight the expansion would hold, in some cases just as significant as the binding legal effect itself. The memo cites a study which found just the presence of an official anti-discrimination policy may have been enough to raise awareness and lead potential discriminators- conscious or not about their actions- to reevaluate how they approach the situation.

Objections in prior debate from City Councilmen have included that protections already exist under current state and federal laws, so that may mean less of a need to add local protections. Putting aside the gaps noted in the memo, the OGC said the scope and how the potential new expansion would interact with state and federal laws is something that would have to be examined. Specifically, the new City protections would not be allowed to conflict with any established state or federal laws.

Finally, the OGC says the City must consider the ramifications any change in the anti-discrimination laws would have on Florida’s religious freedom legislation.

Moving forward

The OGC stressed that this memo is not a policy opinion, but a tool lawmakers can be used if- and likely when- this debate does surface once again. Ultimately, the memo makes it clear it’s up to the elected officials to determine “the best interests of the community they serve” and act from there.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

The Latest News Headlines

  • A couple has been indicted on accusations that they murdered their deaf teenage son and then burned down their house to cover up the crime, the Associated Press reported. >> Read more trending news  According to the Chenango County Sheriff’s Office in New York, Ernest F. Franklin II, 35, and his wife, Heather Franklin, 33, of Guilford, New York, were charged with second-degree murder, arson and tampering with physical evidence. The two were indicted Friday on charges of second-degree murder in the death of their adopted son, 16-year-old Jeffrey Franklin, People magazine reported. Following an investigation of a fire on March 1 at the family’s 1,300-square-foot home, the couple was arrested. Investigators believe they set fire to their home to cover up the killing of their son. An autopsy determined he died prior to the fire, according to the sheriff’s office. Local law authorities have not said how or when the boy was killed. The Franklins got married in 2011 and adopted Jeffrey six or seven years ago, the sheriff’s office said. According to People magazine, Ernest is an Iraq War veteran. Heather wrote in posts on her Facebook page that she is pregnant. The Franklins are being held without bail. They entered a plea of not guilty. “People are asking themselves, ‘How could this happen?'” Chenango County Sheriff Ernest Cutting Jr. told People magazine. “Certainly for the public here, it’s a mix of anger and frustration and disappointment.” Just days before Heather Franklin was arrested, she posted an update on her Facebook page about how much she missed her son, who she called JR. She also informed friends and family that she and her husband had added their “needs” and “wants” to the CheckedTwice.com Family Gift Registry because they lost everything in the fire. A GoFundMe page was also established, but it has been taken down. The Associated Press reported that police who responded to a 911 call about 1:15 a.m. on March 1 found the Franklin’s house, located about an hour away from Syracuse, engulfed in flames. Jeffrey was inside and unable to escape the fire, according to the sheriff’s office. Authorities initially said the cause of the fire appeared to be a wood stove, the residence’s main heating source. “People are wondering how anybody could do something so brutal to a developmentally disabled and handicapped 16-year-old boy,” Cutting told People. “There are a lot of people who would have taken him. There are organizations that would have taken care of him. Why resort to that? … It’s just a terrible, terrible tragedy.”
  • A beloved music teacher from San Jose Elementary will no doubt be on the hearts and minds of students and staff as they return from spring break. Deborah Liles was found dead in her Panama Park home on the northside late last week. Her car was recovered over the weekend not far from her home. Liles' gold 2010 Buick LaCrosse was found on Golfair Boulevard on Saturday and JSO is now asking for the public's help identifying who was driving it.  Neighbors said police found the car behind an abandoned house near Notter Avenue. Police call the case a murder, and Liles’ children said she'd been a victim of several crimes in the past. “I don’t know about the circumstances. I don’t know if they’re coincidences happening. I don’t know if there’s a connection between what happened then and what happened now,' Liles' daughter Rachel Sirmans said. 'We really want to find those answers.” 'Just the condolences, completely unknown numbers that text us…I was your mother's music student in third grade and I'm in high school now”, said Liles’ son Gerald. JSO says this is an active ongoing investigation.   Anyone who knows anything about this murder is asked to contact the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office at 904-630-0500 or email JSOCrimeTips@jaxsheriff.org. To remain anonymous and receive a possible reward up to $3,000 contact Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS.
  • Hannah Eimers, 17, was driving her father’s car in November when she lost control of the vehicle and slammed into a guardrail on the driver’s side, killing her. Months later, Eimers’ father received a bill from the Tennessee Department of Transportation to replace the guardrail. According to the Knoxville News-Sentinel, Steven Eimers got the $3,000 bill four months after Hannah’s death but refused to pay it and called the model of the guardrail “horribly designed.” He told the News-Sentinel that he couldn't believe that the state would “bill my daughter for the defective device that killed her.” >> Read more trending news Rather than deflecting the car or absorbing its impact, the guardrail, which was removed from the department’s list of approved products a week before the crash, reportedly impaled the vehicle and struck Hannah in the head and chest, killing her instantly. “I’m shocked,” Eimers told the News-Sentinel. “The audacity. What bothers me is that they’re playing Russian roulette with people’s lives. They know these devices do not perform at high speeds and in situations like my daughter’s accident, but leave them in place.” Mark Nagi, a spokesman for the Tennessee Department of Transportation, insisted that the bill was sent as a result of a “mistake somewhere in processing' and apologized. He also said Eimers will not have to pay the bill, which covered both the cost of labor and materials. Read more here.
  • A Clay County family has been left with nothing after a fire at Highland Apartments. Clay County Fire Rescue said the flames destroyed all of their belongings. Neighbors said rescue crews flew through the complex shortly after 11 a.m. Sunday. “I just saw a lot of smoke,' neighbor Ron Winstead told Action News Jax. 'I couldn’t really see but maybe 20-30 feet in front of me because it was so smoky. It was really bad.” Officials said the fire started in apartment 1102 and quickly spread, impacting four apartments and severely damaging two units. Fire rescue officials said a child alerted adults to the fire in a bedroom. There were no working smoke detectors in the unit, they said. It took 33 firefighters from Clay County, St. Johns County and Orange Park 20 minutes to get control of the flames. No people or pets were injured. Red Cross assisted tenants, all of whom are being housed in other units onsite. The State Fire Marshall is investigating what caused the fire.
  • Six people were sent to the hospital after a car collided with a Jacksonville Transportation Authority bus on Normandy and I-295.  In the crash report from the Florida Highway Patrol, the bus was traveling east on Normandy Boulevard in the outside lane. A Chevrolet Malibu was attempting to turn left onto I-295 South on the ramp from Normandy Boulevard failing to yield to oncoming traffic and collided with the bus.  After the initial impact, the bus then collided with another car and then continues on Normandy before colliding with a traffic control power box on the right shoulder.  The driver of the Chevy Malibu, the driver of the bus, and the four passengers were taken to the hospital with minor injuries.  The driver of the Chevy will be facing failure to yield to oncoming traffic charges. 

The Latest News Videos