On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
50°
Sunny
H 71° L 50°
  • cloudy-day
    50°
    Current Conditions
    Sunny. H 71° L 50°
  • clear-day
    67°
    Afternoon
    Sunny. H 71° L 50°
  • cloudy-day
    63°
    Evening
    Partly Cloudy. H 71° L 50°
Listen
Pause
Error

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Attorney for El Faro Captain’s widow requests that the MBI report be “substantially revised”
Close

Attorney for El Faro Captain’s widow requests that the MBI report be “substantially revised”

Attorney for El Faro Captain’s widow requests that the MBI report be “substantially revised”
Photo Credit: Stephanie Brown
Crew families places 33 black ribbons at the front of the hearing room on the final day of the public portion of the El Faro sinking Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation

Attorney for El Faro Captain’s widow requests that the MBI report be “substantially revised”

In a 27 page letter Action News Jax has obtained, the attorney for the captain’s widow, Bill Bennett, urges the commandant of the Coast Guard to make corrections to the Marine Board Report.

The letter is in response the Coast Guard’s Marine Board of Investigation report released in October. That report is separate from the NTSB report that was released Tuesday. 

Capt. Michael Davidson's actions have been scrutinized more than anyone else’s and with good reason. 

He was the master of El Faro and thus responsible for the ship and its crew. 

But Bennett said there’s more to it. 

“The El Faro was not lost because of one single event. She certainly was not lost because she transited near a hurricane. She was lost because of a confluence of several events, including water on deck entering a scuttle which was inadvertently left open,” wrote Bennett. 

Bennett called parts of the Marine Board Report inaccurate. 

He stated in the letter that the Marine Board Report "unfairly" omitted facts about the captain's professionalism, skills and safety culture. Including testimony during public hearings that he was a "meticulous" captain who was "safety conscious”. 

He also called into the question the Marine Board’s statement that the master “failed to carry out his responsibilities”. 

The Marine Board Report said Capt. Davidson failed to download the 11 p.m. Bon Voyage System data package. But Bennett said there’s a reason for that. 

“The evidence establishes, however, that the MBI’s analysis is flawed. Communications captured by the VDR establish the Third Mate provided Capt. Davidson with the most up to date weather data available, i.e., the 1100 SAT-C weather forecast. Downloading the 11:00 BVS weather package, which was based upon a forecast hours older than the 1100 SAT-C weather, was unnecessary,” wrote Bennett. 

An open scuttle is one of the biggest reason El Faro flooded so quickly. The letter states it was “inadvertently left open after the Chief Mate and Capt. Davidson ordered the deck secured for heavy weather.” 

According to Bennett, Capt. Davidson was experienced in sailing in heavy weather and had no reason to believe that the weather would contribute to the loss of El Faro. 

“At that time, Capt. Davidson was unaware, and had no reason to know, of the El Faro’s wind heel vulnerabilities or that a scuttle was left open and the vessel was taking on water,” wrote Bennett. 

Bennett reiterates that there’s no single primary cause for the unfortunate event and said that’s backed up by the 38 casual factors listed in the Marine Board Report. 

At the conclusion of the letter, he urged the commandant to consider his comments and requested that the Marine Board Report be “substantially revised”.

Read More

The Latest News Headlines

  • A man was found dead in a home in the Whitehouse area of Jacksonville’s westside.  Jacksonville Police say the victim was shot inside of a home on W. Beaver Street near Chaffee Road.  JSO is working to speak with people who were at the house and in the area at the time of this morning’s shooting. 
  • Coming off a chilly and mainly dreary weekend, some nice weather is ahead this week.  Action News Jax Chief Meteorologist Mike Buresh says we’ll start a warming trend with afternoon temperatures today in the mid and upper 60’s.  By Tuesday we’ll see more sunshine and warmer temps in the upper 60’s and low 70’s.  Our next cold front approaches and passes by the end of the weekend bringing our next best shot at some rain.  
  • A search is underway for an escaped work release inmate who was able to somehow remove his GPS ankle monitor.   The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office says 36-year-old Victor Nash failed to return from work release on Sunday. He was last seen in the area of Hogans Creek near North Catherine Street.  Jail records show Nash was arrested in August for three counts of burglary and was due to be released in June.   JSO says Nash was wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt, blue jeans and black sneakers at the time he fled. Anyone who has seen or knows the whereabouts of Victor Nash is asked to contact the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office at 904-630-0500.  To remain anonymous and receive a possible reward up to $3,000, contact Crime Stoppers at 1-866-845-TIPS.
  • Four people are dead and six hurt after gunfire erupted Sunday night at a backyard football watch party in Fresno, California, authorities said. >> Read more trending news  Here are the latest updates: Update 3:23 a.m. EST Nov. 18: According to the Fresno Bee, the shooting occurred shortly before 8 p.m. outside a home on East Lamona Avenue.  'Everyone was watching football this evening when unknown suspects approached the residence, snuck into the backyard and opened fire,' Fresno police Lt. Bill Dooley said late Sunday. The slain victims were all men in their mid-20s to mid-30s, the Bee reported. Five others who were shot are being treated at Community Regional Medical Center, while a sixth victim who suffered 'a graze wound' was taken to a different hospital, CNN reported. Police have not released any information about possible suspects or a getaway vehicle, the outlets reported. Original report:  A family gathering was disrupted by gunfire when a shooter opened fire, striking at least nine people during a backyard football watch party in California, police say.  An unknown suspect snuck into the backyard and started firing indiscriminately while multiple people were watching a football game around 7 p.m., KMPH reported.  Several people were taken to the hospital. This is a developing story. Check back for updates. 
  • A missing Florida teen with autism has been found, Orlando police said. >> Read more trending news  Here are the latest updates: Update 12:37 a.m. EST Nov. 18: The Orlando Police Department said John Baker was located, WFTV is reporting. Original report: Authorities in Orlando, Florida, are searching for a missing 15-year-old boy.The Orlando Police Department said John Baker was last seen in the area of Colonial Plaza Mall in the 2400 block of East Colonial Drive. Officers said he was last seen wearing an Ohio State Buckeyes T-shirt. They said he is autistic and has the mental capacity of a 6-year-old. Baker stands 5 feet, 11 inches tall and is 150 pounds.  Anyone with information regarding Baker's location is urged to call law enforcement.

The Latest News Videos