On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
73°
Sct Thunderstorms
H 86° L 61°
  • cloudy-day
    73°
    Current Conditions
    Sct Thunderstorms. H 86° L 61°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    83°
    Afternoon
    Sct Thunderstorms. H 86° L 61°
  • cloudy-day
    80°
    Evening
    Partly Cloudy. H 86° L 61°
Listen
Pause
Error

The latest top stories

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest traffic report

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

The latest forecast

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Florida Supreme Court sets rules for existing death row inmates
Close

Florida Supreme Court sets rules for existing death row inmates

Florida Supreme Court sets rules for existing death row inmates

Florida Supreme Court sets rules for existing death row inmates

A Jacksonville man is being taken off death row while another is seeing his stay of execution lifted, as the Florida Supreme Court continues to unravel new rules around the state’s death penalty sentencing scheme.

The two cases involved deal with Mark Asay, sentenced to death for killing two black men in 1987 in racially motivated incidents, and John Mosley, sentenced to life in prison for the murder of his girlfriend and to death for the murder of his infant son in 2004.

Earlier this year, the US Supreme Court ruled in Hurst that the state’s death penalty sentencing scheme is unconstitutional, because it required the jury to make a majority recommendation, but had the judge issue the final sentence. The High Court said it’s unconstitutional to allow the judge to consider factors that weren’t found by the jury.

Florida lawmakers passed a new sentencing scheme that required a ten vote majority, but the Florida Supreme Court recently found that to be unconstitutional as well, holding in Perry that a death sentence must be imposed by a unanimous jury. That ruling did not explicitly settle what would happen with inmates already on death row who were sent there by a non-unanimous jury.

Now, these two new rulings- Asay and Mosley- are giving some clarity to that, and the dividing line is the 2002 Ring case decided by the US Supreme Court.

In Ring, the Court found Arizona’s death penalty sentencing scheme unconstitutional because a sentencing judge, with no sitting jury, could find aggravating circumstances needed to impose a death sentence. Florida’s law was discussed in the ruling, but the Florida cases were not explicitly mentioned, leaving it to the Florida Supreme Court to interpret the impact. The State Court determined Ring did not impact Florida, because the state had- at the time- a hybrid capital sentencing scheme. That decision was, however, a matter that deeply divided the court.

In the US Supreme Court’s Hurst ruling earlier this year, it was concluded that Ring did, in fact, apply in Florida, noting that while the jury advises, the judge still has freedoms that should not be allowed.

As a result, the Florida Supreme Court says Mosley, who based many of his appeals on Ring, but was denied, should get a new penalty phase. The ruling says the appeals were turned down because of the precedent that was set with Ring, so “fundamental fairness” requires Hurst to be retroactive in his case, now that the Court has a new interpretation that Ring applies to Florida.

The ruling goes further to say Hurst should be applied to other defendants whose sentences became final after Ring as well. Because the fundamental objection is that Mosley and others were sentenced without a unanimous jury- which has since been ruled unconstitutional- it’s likely that the Hurst retroactivity is only for those who received death penalties without a unanimous jury.

Asay’s case, however, is a different story.

The Florida Supreme Court says cases that were completed before Ring, like Asay, should not be granted a new penalty phase, because they “extensively relied on the constitutionality of Florida’s death scheme based on the decisions of the United States Supreme Court”. Additionally, the State Court says a substantial number of cases would be upended if this ruling were retroactive, and it would be difficult to reassemble witnesses and evidence that is decades old.

In March, the Florida Supreme Court stayed Asay’s execution “pending further order”. That stay of execution has now been lifted.

Read More

The Latest News Headlines

  • In a shocking video that may be difficult for some to watch, a WSOC-TV viewer captured footage of hundreds of birds scattered across the ground near the entrance of the NASCAR Hall of Fame in Charlotte, North Carolina, after flying into the side of the building. >> Read more trending news  Hollie Cameron's disturbing cellphone video shows dozens of birds lying on the ground outside the building and captures other birds crashing into the large windows. WSOC reporter Gina Esposito spoke with the Carolina Waterfowl Rescue, who said their rehab team responded to the NASCAR Hall of Fame around 11 p.m. and treated hundreds of birds. They said a total of 310 birds hit the windows of the building. Roughly one-third of those birds were dead when they arrived, and another third was seriously injured. The rest appeared to be stunned but will be OK, the organization said. >> Watch the clip here (WARNING: Some viewers may find the video below disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.) In the video, Cameron watched as a bird crashed into the window and then fell to the ground, joining dozens of others. Cameron told WSOC that she was working in the area when she started recording on her phone around 9 p.m. You can hear her talking with a security guard who claims the phenomenon had been going on for about an hour. 'Oh my God, look at them all,' Cameron says in the video. 'There's something wrong with them. This is not OK.' Carolina Waterfowl Rescue posted more video on Facebook of the birds at their facility. About 100 of the surviving birds are being treated for broken wings and fractures. The rescue group said the birds are chimney swifts and that the colony lives in a roost. They think something disturbed the colony Tuesday night, causing the birds to fly into the windows at the NASCAR Hall of Fame. Carolina Waterfowl Rescue officials told WSOC that this was not a naturally occurring event and the birds' migration could not have been a factor because the swifts only migrate during the day. They plan to investigate more on Wednesday. CMPD reportedly responded to the scene to begin cleaning up the birds. Carolina Waterfowl Rescue said rehabbing the injured birds is expensive, and they desperately need volunteers since the birds will need to be hand-fed. Visit their Facebook page for more details on how you can help.
  • Plan to drive through times of scattered showers today ahead of a cool front that will bring drier, more refreshing air to end the week.  Action News Jax Meteorologist Garrett Bedenbaugh says some rain may be heavy at times with a few rumbles of thunder.  Overall rainfall totals are not expected to be great, but the rainfall is needed.  By Thursday morning you’ll begin to feel a change with drier air and high temperatures only in the upper 70’s.  Friday morning lows may fall into the upper 50’s in some neighborhoods, and high temperatures will only be in the upper 70’s.  The weekend is looking a little warmer and wetter at times with a few showers on Saturday and scattered showers on Sunday. 
  • Four separate shootings over a 24-hour period in Jacksonville has left at least six people wounded and, so far, no arrests have been announced by police.  Early this morning a man was shot on W. 17th Street, near RV Daniels Elementary School.  He was taken to a local hospital with a single gunshot wound to the leg. JSO had no suspect description and was asking for tips to Crime Stoppers at 866-845-TIPS.  Just after 10 pm on Tuesday, two young men between the ages of 17 and 20 were shot while sitting in a vehicle on Timmerman Lane. Both shooting victims had non-life-threatening injuries. JSO had no evidence to confirm if this was a drive-by shooting.  Around 5:20 pm on Tuesday, police were called to a shooting on Orton Street, where two men were treated and transported to a hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. No suspect information was given at the scene by detectives.  On Miss Muffet Lane on the westside just after 6 pm on Tuesday, police responded to reports of shots fired. An off-duty officer was called about a gunshot wound victim at Park West ER. He was taken to Orange Park Medical Center in critical condition.  According to JSO, two groups of people in two separate cars that left the area were being questioned by detectives.  
  • A Pennsylvania mom is in critical condition after police said she killed her children and husband, then shot herself, Philadelphia police said. >> Read more trending news  Here are the latest updates: Update 5:49 a.m. EDT Oct. 16: Authorities have identified the woman accused of killing her children and husband late Monday in Philadelphia's Tacony neighborhood, multiple news outlets are reporting. According to WPVI-TV, Damyrra Jones Alcindor, 28, also shot herself, police said. As she was rushed to a nearby hospital, she reportedly told officials she did not want to be resuscitated. Philadelphia police Homicide Capt. Jason Smith said Alcindor admitted to fatally shooting her two daughters, ages 10 months and 4 years, as well as their father, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported Tuesday afternoon. Although police did not release the victims' names, a family member identified them as Max Alcindor, 38; Maxilla, 4; and Damaya, 10 months, WCAU-TV reported. Investigators said Alcindor, who legally bought the handgun earlier Monday, is facing murder charges in the case, according to WCAU. Original report: According to KYW-TV and the Philadelphia Inquirer, the deadly shooting occurred just before 10 p.m. Monday at a home in Philadelphia's Tacony neighborhood. Police said the 29-year-old woman fatally shot her two daughters, ages 10 months and 4 years, as well as their 35-year-old father. All three victims suffered gunshot wounds to the head, authorities said. When police arrived at the Hegerman Street home, they discovered the woman outside 'lying on top of a gun,' the Inquirer reported. Authorities said the woman, who apparently shot herself, was taken to a nearby hospital. Philadelphia police have not released the names of the woman or the victims, the news outlets reported. Read more here or here.
  • Authorities in Indiana said a baby is alive and well after someone discovered the child inside a plastic bag near a fence in Seymour. >> Read more trending news  According to the Tribune and WAVE-TV, police responded to a call about the infant just before 4 p.m. Tuesday. A resident, who had been walking a dog off South Jackson Park Drive, found the child about 60 feet away from the street, investigators said. Crews rushed the baby to a nearby hospital, the news outlets reported. Doctors said the child is healthy, according to WAVE. Seymour police have not yet made any arrests in connection with the incident, the Tribune reported. Read more here or here.

The Latest News Videos